The council approved a series of consent‑calendar items—including investment policy changes, IT upgrades, GIS licensing, and inclusionary housing fees—while maintaining opposition to SB 710 and authorizing the mayor to send letters of support for mental‑health bills.
Council adopts inclusionary housing in‑lieu fee resolution189:26
Council adopts Hispanic Heritage Month resolution225:29
Council reaffirms opposition to SB 710 and authorizes mayor letters of support for mental‑health bills93:12
Summary
The September 6, 2023 Monterey Park City Council meeting combined staff‑communication updates with a robust consent‑calendar agenda. The council first heard presentations from the Fire Department, Library, and Police on emergency preparedness, library hours, and a new firearm‑safety portal. No motions were adopted during those brief presentations. The meeting then moved to the consent‑calendar, where several items were approved by unanimous vote: a new investment policy (Item 3D) that would allocate roughly $25‑$26 million in short‑term bonds through Chandler Asset Management, an amendment to the Network Magic network‑security contract (Item 3F) for $228,900, an enterprise GIS license from ESRI, a HUD consolidated annual performance and evaluation report (CAPER), and a resolution establishing city‑wide in‑lieu fees for inclusionary housing. The council also adopted a resolution proclaiming September 15–October 15 as National Hispanic Heritage Month. In policy discussion, the council reaffirmed its opposition to SB 710 and authorized the mayor to send letters of support for mental‑health legislation (SB 326 & AB 531). No substantive votes were taken on the memorial‑committee discussion, which was deferred to a future meeting. Throughout, council members and staff exchanged questions and clarifications; public comments were limited to a handful of traffic‑safety concerns at Chandler/ Hellman and a few remarks on library programming.
▶Transcript
Unknown Speaker• -
Tem its level seven-systems in its level seven-systemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystemsystem
Good evening. I'm going to go ahead and call our meeting to order. Thank you so much for coming out tonight. I want to go ahead and get started by reading our mission statement. The mission of the City of Monterey Park is to provide excellent services to enhance the quality of life for our entire community. and our land acknowledgement. We would like to acknowledge that the land we inhabit today was once known as the Tavangar, the home of the Gabriolino Tongva people. We show our respect to the Gabriolino Tongva people as well as all of indigenous peoples past, present, and future and honor their labor as original caretakers of this land. We commit to uplifting the Gabriolino Tongva people and we invite you to acknowledge the history and join us in caring for this land. We're going to go ahead and get started with our flag salutes.
Unknown Speaker• -
If you could please stand.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
And tonight we have the Monterey Park Firefighter Explorers. ! ...
Unknown Speaker• -
... ... ... ... ... ...
Unknown Speaker• -
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America.
Unknown Speaker• -
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic of the to which you stand, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
Unknown Speaker• -
Prepare to design colors.
Unknown Speaker• -
Forward march.
Unknown Speaker• -
Bowers, bowers, bowers, bowers, bowers, march.
Unknown Speaker• -
Lord march.
Unknown Speaker• -
Please take your seats.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
And thank you to the Monterey Park Fire Explorers.
Unknown Speaker• -
City Clerk, if we could take a roll call.
City Clerk Maychelle Yee• -
Council Member Lo
Unknown Speaker• -
Present Council Member Yu Here Council Member Go Present Mayor Pro Tem Wong Present Mayor Sanchez Present We have a quorum Thank you
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
City Manager, do we have any agenda additions or deletions or changes?
Inez Alvarez• -
Yes, Mr. Mayor, thank you We would like to do two additions to staff communications We'll be adding Public Works and also Police Department
Unknown Speaker• -
And Mr. Mayor, on item 3i.
Karl Berger• -
3i has a former draft of the ordinance. It doesn't reflect the ordinance that was actually introduced during the council meeting
Unknown Speaker• -
at the last council.
Karl Berger• -
specifically included the language that was stricken by the City Council
Unknown Speaker• -
with regard to concealed weapons permits.
Karl Berger• -
And so the actual second reading will not have that language in it. In any event, that was the original draft that was presented for introduction and through inadvertence we simply didn't strike out that one particular item.
Unknown Speaker• -
That is all.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you.
Do we have any public comments? communications? Yes, we do.
City Clerk Maychelle Yee• -
First speaker, Sarkis Antonian.
Unknown Speaker• -
Good evening, Mayor, Council, staff, audience. As you probably know, if you have Spectrum, you're not getting Channel 7, so we were told yesterday,
Unknown Speaker• -
they call them up you'll get your $15 off and that's to me when the big one hits god forbid it hits we need news to be watching what's going on and they're cutting out why because their stock was like $190 share and now it's like about 80 something or 90 so that's what they're that's what they're doing so now they're trying to push this mask mandates on people and I don't know how How many of you looked up, what are the people I told you to look up?
Unknown Speaker• -
Those three people? Well, Nomi Wolf was on today. And you young, well, this, okay, the three of us, we took the Johnson & Johnson. Since then, I never felt the same. So your Pfizer is the first one, Moderna, and Johnson & Johnson. So Dr. Nomi Wolf has about 20 lawyers. They're going after them. And she has documents that those vaccines do not do anything.
And they're going to put it in the flu shot, like I've been telling you. Everything like that's what's going on. So look it up. Dr. Nomi Wood, Robert Malone, who is the founder of the MARA, the vaccine, not this garbage they're pulling on us. And Dr. McAuliffe, and one stuff that you should be taking, which we do, is Dr. His dead doctors don't lie. Tangy tangerine, there's all kinds of supplements to get away from the gluten, to get away from the junk food.
Unknown Speaker• -
Yeah, I'm a junk food junkie. If anybody should attack or stroke, should be me.
Unknown Speaker• -
I can remember the times eating at McDonald's, Push you to the McDonald's. That would be an easy way to do it. Dr. Wallach. I mean, I forgot. Well, I'll tell you the name tomorrow. I'll call people up. Okay, so this max doesn't do anything. In the vaccine is the spike protein. It leaks out. So the more shots you take, the more of your immune system gets weak. So those three doctors that I told you about, look it up. And I suggest you not to have these employees here to be using that mask. But that mask, the blue masks, what it does, it breaks up and goes into your lungs and get asbestos on it. And all they're doing is just starting up another election like they did. Those drop boxes out there, that should have been gone a long time ago after the 2020 election. Because that was done by your Zuckerberg. your Facebook, all of LA County, those things, that's illegal. You have law enforcement here, that should be out of there by today. That was done illegally. And then everything that was done in the 2020 election, and then they're going after one guy, they're not going after the other. And being on my dad's side, it's from Russia,
Unknown Speaker• -
and all that money is going directly to Ukraine. back in the day when Russia had all those countries, the money would go to Russia first.
Unknown Speaker• -
Then they would think they would send that money. That's billions of dollars. So remember this, on the foreign aid, first is Israel, then Saudi Arabia, then Turkey, and then on down. It was never happened in my lifetime that one country can get that kind of billion dollars and getting again on your global warming push, obviously you people weren't around in the 60s when we would go outside, ride bikes, and do things. You can even go out there. Until every single state that pays for what we're paying for gas tax, the smog, and everything like that, then I'll think about your global warming and your climate change.
City Clerk Maychelle Yee• -
Next speaker, Nancy Curry.
Unknown Speaker• -
Good evening, you all. I want to thank the police officer who saved the stranded motorist on September 2nd at 6.30 a.m.
Unknown Speaker• -
His car was stalled in the intersection of New and Graves in the right turn lane.
Unknown Speaker• -
My home and moony faces overlooks this intersection, so I was very happy to see the police officer arrived to help out before there was an accident.
Unknown Speaker• -
The officer explained to him that he could push his car up the hill on graves and advised him when to put his car neutral and when to apply his brakes.
Unknown Speaker• -
This officer prevented a possible traffic accident. I want to thank our police department for keeping us safe. Thank you.
City Clerk Maychelle Yee• -
Next speaker, Joseph Leon of the San Gabriel Valley Mosquito District.
Unknown Speaker• -
Good evening, Mayor, Council Members, staff, and of course residents of Monterey Park. My name is Joseph Leon. I am the city's representative in the San Gabriel Valley Mosquito and Factor Control District. I name a full agenda today, so I'll be very brief.
Unknown Speaker• -
I'm here because I have residents who are concerned regarding spraying in our city. I did confirm with our district director there is no spraying in Monon Park. There is no West Nile virus risk at this time in Monon Park. Other cities, perhaps, but not in Monon Park. Very fortunate at this time. Also, there was a concern regarding, I guess, some small white bugs flying around. I confirmed with the district that they haven't heard anything about that.
Unknown Speaker• -
But if there's any concerns regarding any kind of insects, mosquitoes, et cetera, just call the district. And the phone number is 626.
Unknown Speaker• -
Should I get it right so you can call?
Unknown Speaker• -
814-9446. And don't be afraid to call. We actually pay for this. This is part of the special assessment of our property tax every year. So it's already, the service is already paid for. Because I know sometimes residents will call me, how much is it going to cost them to come over? No, it doesn't cost anything. It's already paid. And other cities are using the services, so we might as well, Monopark, take advantage of the service. So feel free to call them with any questions you have. and basically they're most concerned regarding West Nile mosquitoes, West Nile virus but they have scientists there so any little thing that you have a question regarding even if they don't deal in that area they can help you with it and the other concern too which I have, I don't know about any of you a lot of ants and that's because of all the rain and humidity so we're just going to have that for a little while sorry about that okay and that's it, the only thing is there's going to be I think a full presentation, schedule I believe October 18th at the council. But today I just came up because the concerns were brought to my attention just recently. Any questions? Questions? Sure, 626-814-9446. And I believe they close around 4.30. So you want to get a hold of them before 4 o'clock. All right, thank you. Thank you. Other speakers?
City Clerk Maychelle Yee• -
Next speaker, Angela Pau Johnson of Mercy.
Unknown Speaker• -
Good evening, esteemed city council members. My name is Angela Pau Johnson. I just wanted to introduce myself.
Unknown Speaker• -
I am the new executive director of Mercy. For those of you who know us or those of you who don't, we have been in the community for over 50 years. I have been a part of the company for two weeks
Unknown Speaker• -
and I'm already astounded by the work that we are doing. We provide home and community-based services to adults with developmental disabilities. And I've been really privileged to be able to steward Mercy's mission and be able to work with such a dedicated team.
Unknown Speaker• -
Some of our staff have been with us for decades, and some of the residents that reside in our homes and are participating in our programs have been there also for several decades.
Unknown Speaker• -
So this is definitely an organization that I feel very proud to be a part of. I know currently we are seeking different partners. I know currently we are seeking different partnerships with the community, Monterey
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you so much for your time. Thank you. Welcome to the City.
Unknown Speaker• -
the city. Thank you. Much appreciated. And if you happen to have any business cards or anything like that, feel free to leave it with our city clerk. Perfect. I might do so next time. I don't have them sent out yet, but absolutely. Okay. Thank you so much. Next speaker, Randy Kaye.
Randy Kay• -
Good evening. The last time I was here, Judy Chu was sitting behind that desk. But I'm here tonight to prevent a traffic fatality at the corner of Chandler and Hellman. Within two weeks of moving to Alhambra on May 23rd, I noticed that it's a dangerous intersection. Chandler runs north-south and ends at Hellman at the north end. Hellman runs east-west perpendicular to Chandler. There's a stop sign on Chandler where it meets Hellman. Traffic must turn left or right onto Hellman. There's parking on both the north and south sides of Hellman. On the south side, there are red zones east and west of Chandler, about 20 feet long. It is difficult to impossible to see beyond the parked cars and trucks to view the traffic coming along Hellman. Traffic making a turn onto Hellman from Chandler must advance almost to the middle of Hellman to be able to see the east-west traffic. That might account for cars not stopping at the stop sign on Chandler. They would have to stop a second time as they inch farther into the intersection to the point where they're actually able to see the cross traffic. The latest four accidents I'm aware of took place Wednesday, August 9th, Thursday the 10th, where an SGV T-boned pushed the car down the road over the curb and into a steel fence into someone's front yard. The woman was also taken to the hospital. and Friday the 11th, which was reported to me by a neighbor, another occurred on Hellman at Chandler on Tuesday, August 15th. I saw three of the four accidents myself. There is a lack of visibility along Hellman due to parking on both sides. There is an exceedingly high number of accidents at that intersection, four in six days. Since Hellman runs from Atlantic to Garfield and Chandler runs between Newmark and Hellman, these two roads are heavily traveled. Hellman is an alternative to Garvey, Valley, Maine, and the 10th Freeway. Many pedestrians traverse that corner and cross the street there. It is a school bus, pick-up, and drop-off location, and children and their parents are present both in the morning and the afternoon. Ralph's big rig trucks and smaller trucks are using Chandler for deliveries to the store. The 106 bus has been rerouted from Atlantic to Chandler. I contacted Public Works in Alhambra soon after moving here, and it was suggested I call the city of Monterey Park. I spoke with Zayed in Public Works at that time, and I was told a traffic study would be done. I called for the results of that traffic study after the first accident I saw on August 9th, and then again after the injury accident on the 10th. Since I did not receive a call back after leaving these messages, I called the city manager's office and then received a call on August 28th from Sean in Public Works. He told me he spent an hour at the intersection on August 28th. He also informed me that a traffic study would be done. That's what I was told the first week of June. We, the neighbors, would like to see something tangible indicating exactly what, if anything, is being done to address the situation at this intersection. I spoke to three drivers of the 106 bus that turns left onto Hellman from Chandler. All three told me it's a difficult turn because it's hard to see cross traffic. Neighbors have told me they've been trying to get something done about this unsafe intersection for years without success. My proposal is two additional stop signs placed on Hellman to make that intersection a three-way stop, westbound in Alhambra and eastbound in Monterey Park. Limit or eliminate parking on the north and south sides of Hellman to improve traffic visibility. Limit truck weight along Chandler to prevent oversized vehicles from entering Hellman from Chandler and ensure that that restriction is enforced. Move the 106 bus route back to Atlantic Avenue. Inform residents of updated results of activities undertaken to address problems at this intersection. And I know this will not be a popular proposal. However, instituting a nominal annual fee for parking in Monterey Park will reduce street parking and encourage residents to utilize the available parking spaces on their properties. It will also discourage Alhambra residents from parking in Monterey Park. This is a safety issue for both Alhambra and Monterey Park residents.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you.
Unknown Speaker• -
I still have time left? Okay.
Randy Kay• -
The Pacific Plaza condos near Emerson has 84 units with two to three parking spaces per unit. That has increased traffic as every car has to travel along Chandler after entering or exiting the building. This happens multiple times per day. The daycare center, which is a commercial facility, has parents dropping off and picking up children, and teachers have to use Chandler to enter and exit the school. The data on accidents from the city of Monterey Park may not be complete, as middle-of-the-road accidents may be captured in the data for Alhambra. Therefore, the total number of accidents is likely underestimated.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you.
Thank you for that information. Do we have any other speakers?
City Clerk Maychelle Yee• -
One final written comment. from Michael. He's a lifelong Monterey Park resident and he also has safety concerns for himself and his 11-month-old daughter at the intersection of Hellman and Chandler. He has noted there has been several near accidents on multiple occasions at that intersection because Hellman and Chandler has no stop sign, no speed bump, no traffic to turn at all. Despite being a three-way intersection that leads from arguably our city's busiest street. In fact, only a few weeks ago, he states, there were three days of consecutive car accidents at the intersection of Hellman and Chandler, two of which resulted in both bodily harm and damage to property. He is hoping, pleading, begging that something can be done to help mitigate these accidents, perhaps a stop sign put in place or red-painted curbs on Hellman
Unknown Speaker• -
to deflect obstructive parking.
City Clerk Maychelle Yee• -
He understands that the intersection of Hellman and Chandler
Unknown Speaker• -
rests on the Monterey Park-Alhambra border,
City Clerk Maychelle Yee• -
which makes any meaningful changes to the street difficult. Perhaps there is something that can be done.
Unknown Speaker• -
He thanks you for your time. Michael Becerra.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you. No other comments?
Unknown Speaker• -
Mr. Mayor, regarding the written comment and the last speaker,
Council Member Henry Lo• -
would it be appropriate to have this concern also forwarded to the Traffic Commission, or is staff already looking to this concern?
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you.
Inez Alvarez• -
City Council, yes, staff is looking at it. If we feel the need to bring it to the Traffic Commission,
Unknown Speaker• -
we will definitely do so.
Unknown Speaker• -
Okay, thank you.
Unknown Speaker• -
I just want to echo that.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
I've heard as well from others that weren't part of the public comment tonight
Unknown Speaker• -
around traffic concerns around On-Hellman
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
and the Atlantic intersection in that area.
Unknown Speaker• -
if appropriate action for the traffic commission,
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
but also would love to get a report. I know Public Works comes occasionally and traffic studies can be notoriously long or take a long time, but if there's anything else we can do to do short-term kind of safety improvements along that intersection or in that stretch of Helmand, I think that'd be, I would love to see that. And if there are other options to bring to the council to consider to address some of these concerns.
Unknown Speaker• -
I think that'd be great. Noted. Thank you.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
And just for public sake, I had a question regarding if residents have a public safety concern, in this case dealing with traffic, is there somewhere within our city website where they can submit a concern
Unknown Speaker• -
that's particularly related to them?
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
I'm thinking more like a form that might be like, do you have a public safety concern? Where is it? And they can leave a comment.
Inez Alvarez• -
I believe most of the time, Mayor and we get these types of concerns, we definitely encourage residents to call our public works department or send us an email. I don't know that we have a specific place on the website for intake of traffic items, but that's definitely something that we can take a look at. Most of the times that we get correspondence or traffic concerns that are brought to our attention are usually by phone, by email, or through our traffic commission. But definitely we can take a look to see if there's some other way to have a space for people to provide us that information.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
I think if there's a likely site or a place within our city website, even the MPK Go app where residents can submit and maybe even furnish images or pictures that could help us realize and know where these traffic concerns are, makes it a lot easier for residents to be able to communicate with the city where these concerns might be.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you so much.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you.
Inez Alvarez• -
It does sound like there's an option on the Go MPK app to report those items as well.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
and I have a comment from council member you
Unknown Speaker• -
I also have experience crossing that from Chandler to
Unknown Speaker• -
Hellman even left or right I mean it's almost impossible I was so I was so worried every time you know I have to cross it so
Unknown Speaker• -
I actually go around and try to avoid that but I know for other car parking
Unknown Speaker• -
on Hellman especially there are big cars I don't know why they have all the big cars there, but it's really
Unknown Speaker• -
blocking the view of us crossing the road, making left or right safely. So yes, I will
Unknown Speaker• -
urge to look into it, especially there's a preschool there, and especially there's a lot of roadblock
Unknown Speaker• -
recently on Atlantic, so people try to cross it and it just makes it a very dangerous spot. So thank you for looking into it. Thank you, staff.
Unknown Speaker• -
Comment from Council Member Ngo? Thank you.
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
And as I think it's already, you mentioned it's already been elevated to our public works,
Unknown Speaker• -
and we're going to take a look at it.
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
But I also want to encourage our speaker, Randy, if you stop by the traffic commission meeting, they meet once a month or once every few weeks. Stop by there and raise your concern there because that's the commission that looks at it, and they'll report back to you probably faster than what we can do.
Unknown Speaker• -
So, okay.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
When are the meetings for the traffic commission?
Unknown Speaker• -
I'm not sure if Sean might know.
Unknown Speaker• -
Our public works director, Sean Igo, has come in to provide us with the dates and times.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you, Sean.
Unknown Speaker• -
Good evening, Honorable Mayor and City Council. I'm Sean O'Gill, Public Works Director.
Shawn Igoe• -
So we have those every third Thursday, and you can be here at 630. And so we do host those. Unfortunately, this next meeting is going to be canceled. We won't have a quorum, so it'll be the next month.
Unknown Speaker• -
And where's the location? Here.
Unknown Speaker• -
Excellent. Thank you.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you.
Unknown Speaker• -
All right.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
We're going to go ahead and head into staff communications, and we have community development.
Unknown Speaker• -
Going first.
Unknown Speaker• -
Good evening, Mayor, members of the City Council. I'm here tonight to inform the City Council and the community about our upcoming workshop regarding our city, our plan. Oh, by the way, my name is Jessica Serrano, your community development director. Next slide.
Unknown Speaker• -
This next slide shows our flyers that we put out for the workshop. We do have copies of this flyer at the table in the back of the room,
Unknown Speaker• -
but we invite you in the community to join us on Monday, September 11th at 6 p.m. at the Bergemeyer Library Friends Room to learn about an exciting initiative that is aimed at revitalizing our downtown and expanding our housing opportunities throughout the city. Participants can join virtually and in person. And we also teamed up with MPK Rewards to provide points that can be redeemed at our local businesses for our participants.
Unknown Speaker• -
And we also recently sent out letters to property owners of properties that are undergoing zone changes. So we encourage those participants, those property owners, to reach out to staff if you have any questions. If you hear from any of your constituents, please direct them to staff, and we're more than happy to provide them with additional information about this initiative. Next slide.
Unknown Speaker• -
To learn more, please visit our website, montereypark.ca.gov, backslash, our city, our plan,
Unknown Speaker• -
to register for the workshop, to review our fact sheet, to view the map of the affected properties.
Unknown Speaker• -
And you can access the website by using the QR code also on the screen. For more questions, please contact our Community Development Department Planning Division at 626-307-1315, or you can email us at planningpermitcounter at montereypark.ca.gov. this concludes my communication please let me know if I can
Unknown Speaker• -
answer any questions
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
thank you Mr. Arano any questions
Unknown Speaker• -
from the council or comments looking forward to a good meeting on Monday
Unknown Speaker• -
Monterey Park. Thank you. Hope to see you there. Thank you. Our next communication is from the fire department. Good evening, Mayor and members of the Council. Fire Chief Matt Halleck. Here tonight as September has been designated as emergency preparedness month and I think we were all reminded how important it is to be prepared just a few weeks ago. when we were faced with a significant weather event. And then on top of that, later that evening, a significant earthquake in Ventura County. So it just shows you that anything can happen at any time. And our preparedness and how we prepare will certainly make things hopefully a lot easier for us in our community. So just wanted to go over some things tonight. Next slide, please. The motto of our emergency preparedness department has always been be prepared, not scared.
Unknown Speaker• -
And to do that is it takes certain things. And there's a saying, a chance favors the prepared individual.
Unknown Speaker• -
And so the more we prepare, the better hopefully off we'll be when that earthquake does hit or we have another significant weather event or whatever type of emergency we're going to be faced with. So the importance is preparation. And that saying failing to plan is planning to fail. And we certainly will want to avoid that. Next slide, please. So I want to talk about understanding what are some emergencies we might face in our home. And, of course, that depends on where you live. So if you obviously live in the high desert, you might be faced with wind events. In the mountains, snow events or something like that. Obviously, in the coastal areas, flooding. So it just depends on where you live. So understanding what you could potentially be faced with. You want to create a plan. Ultimately, it's an escape plan. It's a plan what you're going to do when a type of emergency happens. and the sooner you create that plan, you practice that plan, again, will lead to your better preparation. You want to assemble a kit.
Unknown Speaker• -
We talk about this all day long, having that kit available for you to use at home, in your car, at work.
Unknown Speaker• -
I'll talk about what should be in that kit, but it's important to remember that an earthquake doesn't happen when you're at home, always.
Unknown Speaker• -
It can happen when you're on the 210 freeway and you're stuck on that freeway for seven hours. Do you have a kit? Do you have water? Do you have food?
Unknown Speaker• -
Do you have those things that are going to keep you comfortable until somebody can come and get you or get you off the freeway? Same thing with that work. So it's just important to build that kit, a smaller version of your home kit. And then know what to do during an earthquake or an emergency and after. There are lots of things you can do, and we'll talk about each of those as we progress. So next slide, please. Some common emergencies we're going to face, obviously fires, wildfires. Not around here, thankfully, but obviously northern California, some more of the wildland areas. We're going to see those types of events. Flooding, we just were kind of reminded of that can happen here in Monterey Park. Earthquakes, obviously, it's not if, it's when it's going to happen. We had 5.2 in Ventura County just a couple weeks ago, so we're on the cusp of that big earthquake, so it's preparing. And as we have those, it kind of reminds us that we need to be prepared. Power outages with the summer months, you know, we're always faced with the potential for an outage. And so how do we get through that? Again, we rely so much on that light switch. We'll always provide light. Well, if we have an outage, it may not be there. So just being prepared for that. Medical emergencies, and obviously all those are kind of natural disasters that we might face. Next slide, please.
Unknown Speaker• -
So we have to have that, I mentioned, emergency plan. So we create that plan, and then we practice that plan.
Unknown Speaker• -
And within those plans we should have escape routes. We need to know where to go. You go into businesses and there's a placard on the front that
Unknown Speaker• -
Shows you how you should leave the building if you have to leave in an emergency You should have that same kind of design for your home or your office or where you're wherever you are So that you know where to go where the safe places are to go if you're on the second floor
Unknown Speaker• -
How do I get to the first floor if I can't get to the stairs do I have a Escape ladder that I can get out the window things like that start to get you thinking about those types of emergencies DESIGNATE MEETING POINTS. IS IT ACROSS THE STREET? IS IT A PARTICULAR HOUSE? IS IT A LOCATION WHERE A TREE IS? HOPEFULLY NOT A BIG TREE THAT COULD POTENTIALLY FALL OVER IF IT'S WINDY OR AN EARTHQUAKE. THINK ABOUT THOSE THINGS. ASSIGN RESPONSIBILITIES. WHO'S GOING
Unknown Speaker• -
TO DO WHAT? OBVIOUSLY IF YOU HAVE SMALL KIDS, THAT'S A PRIORITY. IF YOU HAVE THINGS THAT YOU NEED TO REMOVE WITH YOU THAT ARE VERY IMPORTANT, YOU NEED TO DESIGNATE WHO'S GOING
Unknown Speaker• -
TO DO THAT. AND THEN ALSO SPECIAL NEEDS. WE ALWAYS TALK ABOUT OUR PETS. THEY'RE OUR FAMILY members who's going to get the dog or the cat how about elderly family members who's going to take care of them and also those with disabilities how do we account for them and get them into a safe location next slide please and also so emergency contacts obviously your local emergency services 911 non-emergency phone numbers for the city police department fire department are all
Unknown Speaker• -
things that you should have stored somewhere we have everything in our phone everything's in here but what if you didn't have access to this you have
Unknown Speaker• -
it somewhere written down that you can get to in an emergency. Have your neighbors phone numbers. We're kind of isolated into our homes, but do we know who our neighbors are? Are
Unknown Speaker• -
we able to communicate with them? They might be people that you rely on, and they rely
Unknown Speaker• -
on you. Your relatives, having that out-of-state contact, very important in an emergency so
Unknown Speaker• -
everybody can call that person and let them know we're okay. You might not be able to
Unknown Speaker• -
communicate within the county of Los Angeles but you could for some reason
Unknown Speaker• -
established phone line can get you into another state so have that person out of the area so that you can reach out and everybody knows to contact them so that
Unknown Speaker• -
you know that you're you're okay obviously doctors and hospitals and
Unknown Speaker• -
then utility companies you know we stress that we want everybody to be self-reliant for up to 72 hours if not a week that means food water and potentially lighting all those creature comforts we may not get to you for that amount of time because we're going to be so busy with different calls. Same thing with the water department, same thing with Edison, same thing with the gas company. So it's about self-reliance.
Unknown Speaker• -
Next slide, please. So in that kit, there's no set list of what you should have, but obviously
Unknown Speaker• -
water and non-perishable foods and a good supply of that, at least a gallon per person per day. And the water is so easily attainable through Costco or different Smart and Finals, you can buy a lot of it and you can rotate it out after the course of a year making sure that's still good. Non-perishable foods, you know, those different vendors, Costco or camping stores, you can buy the freeze-dried food. You know, it's not, you know, your fancy lobster thermidor or anything
Unknown Speaker• -
like that, but it'll get you through. And, you know, it has a 25-year shelf life. So you can buy
Unknown Speaker• -
it and you can forget it, but it'll be there when you need it. Flashlights and batteries. When we lose power, no candles. Candles are a fire hazard and we want to avoid that. So having good batteries and flashlights available for everybody. First aid supplies, obviously if somebody's injured we're going to be able to take care of that. Blankets and clothing for inclement weather, important documents. You need to think about that on a personal level. What is important to you? Insurance
Unknown Speaker• -
documents, financial documents, health directives, anything like that, have copies of those available
Unknown Speaker• -
and ready to take with you at a moment's notice.
Unknown Speaker• -
And then tools, multi-tools, things that you might be able to need to cut certain things
Unknown Speaker• -
or get a screwdriver here or there to remove something.
Unknown Speaker• -
And, of course, hygiene items, I think, is something we tend to leave off kits, but you have to consider that. Toilet paper, feminine products, things like that,
Unknown Speaker• -
that will make you more comfortable in those times when you might be without service for quite a while. Next slide. Again, check your kit and update it.
Unknown Speaker• -
Stuff could expire. So make sure you can get it and the most important thing with that is don't build a kit and put it somewhere
Unknown Speaker• -
You can't get to it when the earthquake hits okay make it accessible and available so you can get to it So check on its location periodically and then don't forget medications very important medications baby supplies formulas diapers things like that that you may not have access to for quite some time So next slide please some some emergencies we might face fire safety
Unknown Speaker• -
We stress this two times a year always your smoke detectors check your batteries and change them out
Unknown Speaker• -
Your smoke detector when you change your clock so in the spring and the fall check those batteries and your smoke detectors Know your escape routes again going with that plan. How do I get out of my house?
Unknown Speaker• -
How would I get out of the City Hall if I need it to escape in a moment's notice?
Unknown Speaker• -
How would you get out always practice practice that stop drop and roll? We're so Used to that in our childhood and as a teacher you probably do that all day long or you know multiple times per year and so So practice that. You never know when you're going to need it. And then, again, finding that meeting place outside after you have to evacuate. Next slide. So we experienced this a few weeks ago, floods and water safety.
Unknown Speaker• -
Avoid flooded areas. You think that's common sense. We hope that's common sense.
Unknown Speaker• -
But we always see on the news somebody has to be rescued from a car that's, you know, up to their door in water. If it looks like it's unsafe, it is unsafe. Avoid that area. Turn off your utilities. Obviously, electricity does not go well with water. So turn off your utilities, and I'll talk about that here in a second. Have sandbags ready. So we experienced sandbag phenomenon a couple weeks ago.
Unknown Speaker• -
And, you know, that weekend we went through 30 tons of sand for our community members.
Unknown Speaker• -
And that's probably the amount we used in an entire winter season.
Unknown Speaker• -
But it was important. People felt like they had to be prepared. The media, of course, stressed how important it was to have sandbags. So what we are asking our residents is those that came to get sandbags, let's reuse them if we can. So keep them in a place that, you know, the sun doesn't hit those bags because they'll degrade over time with the heat and the sun. Put them away someplace where we can reuse them, and that way we have plenty for everybody moving forward if we have another emergency like that.
Unknown Speaker• -
And then obviously with flooding, keep important items off the ground where they could potentially get damaged. With earthquake preparedness, drop, cover, and hold on. Again, we practiced that, and we're going to practice that in October with the Great Shakeout. I'll talk about that in a second. Secure heavy objects. Use EM wax is another thing that you can utilize. If you have dishes up high, pots, vases, just secure them so when we do have an earthquake,
Unknown Speaker• -
they don't fall and cause an injury to somebody. And emergency drills. So that Great Shakeout, October 19th at 1019.
Unknown Speaker• -
So 1019 at 1019, you can go online.
Unknown Speaker• -
You can register for the Great Shakeout. You can do it at home and just your family.
Unknown Speaker• -
practice it duck cover and hold at work we always do that with the city we evacuate city hall
Unknown Speaker• -
again it's just that repetitive practice that will when the actual event happens we feel comfortable doing those things power outages again no candles flashlights only unplug your appliances when the power turns back on there could be a surge could potentially cause a fire so when that happens for an extended amount of time you want to unplug your appliances and then
Unknown Speaker• -
And keep your battery powered radio. Again, we rely on our phone for information and news, but if it's not available, we have that good old fashioned battery operated radio that will hopefully get us information that we need.
Unknown Speaker• -
During an emergency, again, stay informed with your radio. Hopefully the internet will get you information not always available. Follow that plan. Again, relying back on that plan.
Unknown Speaker• -
If you're able to help others, do so. within your neighborhood, within your family.
Unknown Speaker• -
If you can get to other people to help them and vice versa, if they can help you, that's how we rely on each other in our community. After an emergency, check for injuries. There's always a potential, especially after an earthquake that people got hurt, so let's check for that. Assess damage. One thing I always want to stress is when you see lines that are down, always assume they're energized power lines and avoid them. That's a high priority for not only us, but for the power company. So you can't see electricity. It's very dangerous. If you see that, please avoid that. Reach out to your loved ones and let them know you're okay. That always provides that comfort after an emergency. And then document any damage that you have for later on for your insurance purposes. So what are the first steps we should do in preparation? First thing you can do is join our CERT program, Community Emergency Response Teams. So our next class, October 28th, November 4th, and 11th. So if you haven't already been a part of CERT, join. We teach you all of this stuff in those three weekend classes.
Unknown Speaker• -
It's free. All we ask of is your time. And you'll learn about emergency preparedness, fire extinguisher usage, first aid, CPR certification, all that for you and your community.
Unknown Speaker• -
So that's a great thing to be a part of. The police department has a Citizens Academy. You'll learn a lot of great information within there as well, so sign up for that if available.
Unknown Speaker• -
Nixle is a platform that the city uses to get critical information out to our community. However, it's an opt-in platform. You have to submit your contact information for that message to get to you. So if you haven't done so already, go to nixle.com, enter your zip code, your contact information, and when the city pushes out information about sandbags or what other road closures,
Unknown Speaker• -
anything that's critical to your safety in the city, you'll get that notification through Nixle.
Unknown Speaker• -
Know where your utilities are, how to turn off your gas, your water, and electricity. At 2 a.m., when you smell gas or you hear running water, the last thing you want to do is find where that is. Insert, you'll learn where all those utilities are and how to turn them off. But if, when in doubt, contact your utility company or go online, you can certainly find how to turn off your gas or your electricity. Very important for your safety. We have a emergency preparedness guide that the fire department put together. It's online. It's on prepare mpk.com It's a digital version You can download it and it's got all this information and then some for you to use for your preparedness at home and again practice your plan Thank you and be happy to answer any questions
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
Thank you chief for all of that valuable information any questions or comments from the council?
Unknown Speaker• -
Yes, mr. Mayor. Thank you chief. Thank you. That was a very informative and
Unknown Speaker• -
Certainly I hope for the audience watching and listening that they take advantage of these programs we have to help our residents prepare for a disaster. I have a curious question, actually.
Council Member Henry Lo• -
And again, I know most of the focus has always been on preparing for a disaster.
Unknown Speaker• -
But have we ever done, I guess, a post-disaster type workshop?
Council Member Henry Lo• -
And this is why I bring it up, and certainly I don't think it's ever happened here in the city. but sometimes you hear anecdotally, like, you know, if there's been a disaster, like an earthquake or flood, and you hear things like, you know, people...
Nothing happens here, but I've heard anecdotally we're in situations where people have pretended to be inspectors and it's really to scam someone to extract a fee out of it. So it sounds like a lot of our focus, and it should be, is preparing, but I almost wonder do we also, or can we maybe also think about putting something like post-disaster, how
Unknown Speaker• -
one should react in the post-disaster? Sure, no, absolutely. Absolutely. We do disaster preparedness clinics quarterly.
Unknown Speaker• -
That's something we can incorporate into those deliveries is considering that because we know we talk about cash and carrying cash as part of your kit but having small denominations
Unknown Speaker• -
because unfortunately the worst in people come out in emergencies and they want to take advantage.
Unknown Speaker• -
That gallon of milk that was $3 and you have a $20 bill is now $20. So people take advantage.
Unknown Speaker• -
So yeah, we can certainly add that into a delivery to guide people into
Unknown Speaker• -
How they should be contacted who would contact them in that form so they know if they get a phone call It wouldn't be from FEMA FEMA doesn't make phone calls. It would be certain things like that. So absolutely
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
Mayor Portemua. Thanks chief appreciate the the comprehensive update. I know you shared the website where all these tips and guide information is at. Do we translate any of that to other languages?
Unknown Speaker• -
It is, yes. The guide is translated into Spanish and Chinese on the website, so you can download
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
all versions. Awesome. And then do we put snippets of these tips into the Cascades or anything?
Unknown Speaker• -
Yes, we do. So in October, you'll see the article for the shakeout. And then as we go through the
Unknown Speaker• -
year we always put preparedness tips whether it be for Christmas tree safety swimming pool safety just overall safety tips preparedness tips we put in the
Unknown Speaker• -
cascades on a regular basis great that's super super great and hope you continue
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
that work and I feel like I'm trying to remember on my refrigerator home I think there's a magnet with all the emergency numbers and utility numbers I don't know when I got that from the city but maybe inappropriate time to redo that at various times of the year to either as a giveaway or some sort of thing
Unknown Speaker• -
where people can
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
have those numbers that are such a...
Unknown Speaker• -
In this guide that you can download, there's a section for you to write all those numbers down.
Unknown Speaker• -
So you can certainly
Unknown Speaker• -
download the guide and then you can update it, but absolutely.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
Thank you so much for that information.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
Our next presentation is from the library.
Unknown Speaker• -
Good evening, Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, City Council members. My name is Lauren Frazier, and I'm the interim senior children's librarian at the library.
Unknown Speaker• -
So I'm here to provide some updates for the library, as well as let you know some of the awesome programs we have going on in the next month or so. So first, and one of the most important things, is we're thrilled to announce that we're expanding
Unknown Speaker• -
our open hours at the library. So six full day service is officially here with our first Monday open being next Monday, September 11th. So our new hours will be 12 to 8 Monday, Tuesday, 10 to 6 Wednesday through Saturday. So one of the most consistent comments we got when we were conducting our strategic plan was community members wanting more access, more open hours. So we're thrilled to address that strategic imperative. Next slide, please. So in celebration of the expansion of hours, please join us at the library for a ribbon-cutting ceremony on Monday, September 18th at 4.30 p.m. A reception and light refreshments will follow in the friends' room.
All right. So also, September is library card sign-up month. So this year's theme is a library card is elemental.
Unknown Speaker• -
So this is a theme that the American Library Association came up with in partnership with the Elemental movie.
Unknown Speaker• -
So get in your element this month by signing up for a library card.
Unknown Speaker• -
It's free, easy, and it gives you access to not just books, but so much more. Next slide, please.
Unknown Speaker• -
All right. So to celebrate National Library Card Sign-Up Month, the library will be out on the town providing pop-up library card sign-up tables. So you can see us at the movie in the park and the farmer's market. We're also partnering with the Alhambra School District for a library card sign-up drive. So this is on the 16th. So second graders have submitted their applications already. We've processed them. They get to come to the library, celebrate getting their new card. with a little gift, so we're excited to be able to provide that. Also, I wanted to talk about all the cool things you can do with your library card besides checkout books. So you can check out our Wi-Fi hotspots. We have Chromebooks for checkout, our California State Parks passes. You can have us print your 3D printing project. You can stream movies for free on Canopy with your library card. You can access our virtual storytime archive, and you can get free homework help online and much more. Next slide. We also wanted to announce coming up on September 30th, we have our Elder Law Day from 10 a.m. to 12.30 p.m. in the Friends Room. So lawyers from the Asian Pacific American Bar Association and Asian Americans Advancing Justice SoCal will be on hand to answer questions about planning your estate. Space is limited, so we request registration. Please contact the library to register for that. Next slide. Also, homework help is coming back. We're very excited about that. So Saturdays from 2 to 4 p.m., high school volunteers are available in the library to provide homework help for elementary school students. But for those who can't come into the library, we have an excellent online resources. This one, BrainFuse Help Now, is especially awesome because it has live one-on-one tutoring. You don't even need a library card to use it. You can just go through our website. so it is for all students k through 12 and even beyond so you can connect with the tutor live online if you have any questions about using help now just please give us a call and we'll walk you through it next slide also we are celebrating hispanic heritage month at the library so that is september 15th to october 15th we have a ton of cool programs we have our spanish bilingual story time, folLod by a craft. We will have our junior friend social. We will have our afternoon matinee. We will be showing La Bamba, and we will have a Crafts of Mexico program as well. Next slide. And we are also celebrating the Mid-Autumn Festival with adult and teen crafts, and they'll be making lanterns. Next slide. And we also have college prep workshops that are sponsored by the Chinatown Service Center. So those are Saturdays at 11 a.m. in the library computer lab. So they will learn how to apply for financial aid, fill out college applications, how to choose the right college, and how to write the college essay. So those are going to be very valuable for high school students. And finally, just a reminder about our library gala, which is happening on October 13th. So from 6 to 9 p.m. at Luminarias. For more information about how to purchase individual tickets or to sponsor a table, you can visit our website, and our gala will be honoring the Monterey Park Fire and Police Departments. All right, so that concludes my presentation. Does anyone have any questions?
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
First off, thank you so much for that presentation, but also all the amazing programming that you do through the library. I always tell people we have the best library in all the San Gabriel Valley.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you. Any questions or comments from Council? Mayor Pro Tem Wong?
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
Just thank you again echoing the mayor's comments.
Unknown Speaker• -
I appreciate all the programming.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
Looking forward to reopening or opening on Mondays going forward. and thank you to the staff for getting that together this year. I don't know if you will know this. I'm just curious, the free mental health drop in counseling services, I don't know if a lot of people are still making use of that given the opening of the Resiliency Center or how uptake of that programming looks like.
Unknown Speaker• -
Christmas coming.
Kristin Olivarez• -
Good evening, Kristen Olivera's interim city librarian. Currently, the staff from Chinatown Service Center is still available on Wednesdays and Fridays.
Unknown Speaker• -
They are located at the entrance to the library, so based on what I've heard, they have had pretty good response.
Kristin Olivarez• -
People just sort of catching them as they're entering the library.
Unknown Speaker• -
so they are still getting a number of people even with the Resiliency Center opening so far as I know.
Thank you so much. And I just had one question.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
For the library card event that's going on this entire month, I just want to say thank you for partnering with Alhambra Unified. I teach in Alhambra Unified, but also my daughters attend Alhambra Unified. But I was wondering if we happen to partner and reach out to any of the other local school districts including Garvey, Montebello, or LAUS. We have some of those schools in our city as well.
Unknown Speaker• -
We haven't contacted to make an official drive,
Unknown Speaker• -
but we have been present at back-to-school nights across various districts.
Unknown Speaker• -
And we're going to go to Hillcrest next week for a back-to-school night.
Unknown Speaker• -
And at back-to-school nights, we have our library card sign-up table.
Unknown Speaker• -
but we're definitely interested in the future in making those partnerships as the like, you know,
Unknown Speaker• -
every child having a library card gets closer.
Unknown Speaker• -
We want to definitely try to make those connections for sure.
Unknown Speaker• -
Excellent. Thank you.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
Our next presentation is recreation and community services.
Unknown Speaker• -
Good evening, Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, members of the City Council my name is Orlando Muto Recreation Supervisor for the City of Monterey Park I'm here to share some updates and some save the dates of our upcoming events next fire I want to take the time to thank everyone who came out to support Langley Center's wildest party of the West we had an
Unknown Speaker• -
amazing turnout our seniors line dance the day away to life sounds and and of the sorry life sounds of rock top next slide I also want to thank everybody who competed in our Langley Center Karaoke Contest. Once again, they had some great singers who sang their favorite tunes. Next slide. Please join us to kick off
Unknown Speaker• -
Hispanic Heritage Month at our Farmers Market as we start the evening on September 14th with our friendly Fred Walk. The walk will begin at 5 30 p.m. Come and enjoy food, craft vendors, and the sound of Mariachi Antonio Navarro. We We will continue the celebration on September 21st by showing Selena.
Unknown Speaker• -
The movie will begin at dusk and will be in conjunction with our Farmer's Market. Langley Center will continue the fun on September 28th. Seniors come out to dance the day away at the fun fiesta party. The event will start at 1 p.m. with Latin music, food, and raffles. And finally, come out to the farmer's market to see Ballet Flucorico Sol de Juego at Barnes Park from 5 p.m. to 6 p.m. that evening on September 28.
Unknown Speaker• -
On Thursday, October 12, please visit Langley Center as they kick off the Dia de los Muertos altar.
Unknown Speaker• -
The altar will stay up until November 2.
Unknown Speaker• -
Next slide.
Unknown Speaker• -
Come join us to honor the lives lost on September 11 at our Patriots Day event. on Monday, September 11th at 8.30 a.m. in front of City Hall. Next slide.
Unknown Speaker• -
And save the dates. We have a few events to save the dates, starting off with Electric Park on October 14th from 4 p.m. to 10 p.m. here at Barnes Park.
Unknown Speaker• -
There will be music, food trucks, games, and vendors. Our next event will be Monster Mash that will be on October 19th from 4 p.m. to 7 p.m. in collaboration with Brugmire Library.
Unknown Speaker• -
It will be here at Barnes Park. please come trick or treat visit all our local vendors and our organizations that will be out
Unknown Speaker• -
there giving out candy both events are free and family friendly I thank you for letting us share and if there's any questions I'm happy to share some but don't forget to continue to follow us
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
on Instagram and our social media thank you so much for all of that amazing programming that you guys are doing in the next couple months and thank you so much for all the events for Hispanic
Unknown Speaker• -
Heritage Month. But any questions or comments from Council? Thank you Mr. Mayor. Again thank you
Council Member Henry Lo• -
again for a great presentation. I know I'm personally looking forward to our second annual Friendly Fred Walk and again thank you for doing the first one last year which included a walk past
Unknown Speaker• -
his family home in Monterey Park. So thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Our next presentation is
Unknown Speaker• -
Public Works. Good evening, Honorable Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem and City Council, Sean Igoe,
Shawn Igoe• -
Public Works Director. Tonight I want to go over some sandbags and how to dispose of those. So, as Chief Halleck pointed out, we gave out nearly 30 tons of sand and over 10,000 sandbags during the recent storm event. And that was just one weekend. So this is typically abnormal, what we normally do even during a normal wet season. So now residents are asking what they should be doing with these handbags. So we're strongly encouraging
or at a minimum out of the sunlight so they can reuse these in the next couple months. Should they feel they need to dispose of them, they can throw them away in their mixed-use trash cans
Unknown Speaker• -
as long as they weigh less than 50 pounds.
Shawn Igoe• -
So if they weigh more than 50 pounds in total, then they'll need to call Athens for a bulky item pickup. Typically, each handbag weighs about 6 to 7 pounds.
Unknown Speaker• -
So that's just for everyone's information so they know what they're disposing of.
Shawn Igoe• -
And again, Athens offers the free service for bulky item pickup.
Unknown Speaker• -
Next slide, please.
Shawn Igoe• -
Worst case, they can always come to our community cleanup event that we're having on October 7th. It's on a Saturday from 8 to 12. So they can also come here and dispose of them there with any other bulky items they want to dispose of at this event. So this is going to be at George Elder Park. Again, this is going to be on Saturday, October 7th.
Unknown Speaker• -
So with that, I'll answer any questions. Thank you. Any questions from Council? Mayor Portamont?
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you, Sean.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
I appreciate everything that public works and the rest of the city staff did to prepare for the storm. Luckily, I think the impacts and the winds were not as impactful as I think we were expecting in the forecast. But still good to be prepared, as was noted earlier. Are we planning to put the sandbag tips in the Cascades or any other avenues to get out?
Unknown Speaker• -
Yeah, we can definitely do that.
Shawn Igoe• -
We also put that on social media, but we'll also do that.
Unknown Speaker• -
We'll put it out there as much as we can to encourage people. Perfect.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
I know when we had that previous meeting, I don't know if it's appropriate to put it on the banners.
Unknown Speaker• -
People seem to read the banners.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
But the more we can do, I think a lot of people got the sandbags and now have no idea what to do with them. And asking them to sit on them for a couple months is probably a lot to ask. But the more we can get out the word to them about keeping that and knowing that El Nino is in store, not knowing for sure if it's going to rain, but the conditions are there for a heavier rainy season, I think,
Unknown Speaker• -
or we want to be prepared to.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
Another separate question, I don't know if you know, I was at Costco yesterday, and I saw at the OIA landfill site that they're doing some work on the slopes there. I don't know if you know what's going on there, if that's just damage from the storm.
Shawn Igoe• -
Most likely that's what it is, but I'm not aware of what they're doing.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
If there's anything worth checking in on there, let me or let the council know, I guess.
Unknown Speaker• -
Sure. I'll do.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you, Sean. Thank you.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
And our last presentation is from the police department.
Unknown Speaker• -
Good evening, Mr. Mayor, City Council. Scott Weiss, Chief of Police. Go ahead and first slide, please. So kind of a memorial date for us. Officer William Gadara was killed in the line of duty September 9th, 1927.
Unknown Speaker• -
He was a brand new officer. He'd been on the department two weeks. He was at Rural and Garvey assisting a motorist that he pulled over and fixing their taillight. While the motorist and he were standing between the two cars, the police car and the civilian car, a driver approaching from another direction swerved to avoid a collision, struck the police car, which then pinned them between the two cars. Officer Goddara was transported to Alhambra Hospital and died at the hospital on the 9th of September, 1927. It's a long time ago. The department remembers it. We have a memorial wall. We keep the remembrance of his passing. He was not a police officer here for very long. It's very difficult to get the information from 1927, But with the help of with Diana Garcia, we're able to mine some information recently. And so we will hopefully put a picture up soon with his with his likeness up in the police department. But, you know, we've only had a few officers killed in the line of duty. And this is one. But it happened many, many years ago. So for us at the department, we still remember it. Next slide, please. So this is a response to some of the communication with council over the last several months. One of the things we're developing at the police department is a link on our police department website for firearm safety. The firearms unit, the training unit within the police department is creating that website, and anybody who accesses the city webpage, goes to the police department page, will be able to access the different subpages within that. Some of the topics we're going to talk about in there are firearm safety. We'll have links to different firearm safety organizations. We've partnered with a child safe organization, which has provided us with 100 safety locks for firearms. We'll be pushing that out through the website and through social media. And anybody in the public who needs a lock for their firearm at home, if they haven't purchased one in the last 10 years, I believe, is when the law changed in California. If it's an older firearm, we would like them to get a hold of us, and an officer can either drop it off at the house or they can come up to the department, pick up some literature, and we'll show them how to install that on their gun. But those are available. We received them in the mail just yesterday, so we're getting that information out to the public as soon as we can. But that's available for free. We're going to talk about on the website how to safely dispose of firearms. Believe it or not, we get dozens of people every year that call the police department. They're going through their dad's stuff. They're going through the garage. They find an old firearm. They don't want it. They don't know what to do with it. They don't feel comfortable with it. They can call the police department. We'll either send an officer out to the field or some of them bring them into the station. And we have a procedure for that that we'd like the public to understand so you don't walk in with the shotgun over your shoulder or whatever it is. But we'll have that in there and explain how people can safely turn in firearms. All those firearms are brought in. We book them into evidence and then we destroy those firearms. There'll be a link to California firearms laws through the Department of Justice. and we'll link with their website. And there's a lot of frequently asked questions that people can go to. And I was on it today to see some of the different topics. And there's dozens and dozens and dozens of topics that people that have questions can access. And it comes right out of the firearms unit with Department of Justice.
Unknown Speaker• -
We're also going to put a link in there to explain to people how if a firearm is taken for a purpose here
Unknown Speaker• -
and it's judicially released to them, which a judge can release a firearm to somebody. If it's taken for safekeeping or for whatever reason, they have to go through a court procedure to get it back.
Unknown Speaker• -
But once that's done, there's a procedure within the department that they have to produce that court paperwork
Unknown Speaker• -
before we release those firearms. And that's not our decision. That's a decision that's made by case law or by statute, and a judge has to sign off on that.
Unknown Speaker• -
So we'll explain that in there. And then we'll also have a link to the new gun violence restraining order procedures that LA County is developing right now.
Unknown Speaker• -
It's a county-wide process that will be in place pretty soon, and we'll have a linkage there and an explanation and some suggestions of how people can navigate that. And ultimately, we'll fall back on us at the police department to figure out how we're going to execute that court order if it does get approved.
Unknown Speaker• -
Next slide, please.
Unknown Speaker• -
California State Senate Bill No. 2 is now in committee. It's out of committee, and it's, I believe, on the floor. I'm not going to go through each of these sections, but what it does is it amends the California concealed weapons laws and makes them very restrictive. And these are just some of the places that will be restricted if SB 2 passes in California.
Unknown Speaker• -
It affects a dozen or so different sections, and way too many for me to list on here, but if it gets to the governor and it is signed, these are some of the restricted areas that will be, for any CCW holder, they won't be able to carry there. Now, that goes above and beyond our local rules, but if you see on there, government buildings and parks are listed in the state law. So we'll have kind of double coverage, if you will. Next slide, please.
Unknown Speaker• -
I did a little bit of, We talked about signs and private businesses. Businesses in town are private property.
Unknown Speaker• -
Private property owners, as of right now, with the way state law works, they can restrict anybody on their private property.
Unknown Speaker• -
CCW holders aren't specifically precluded from carrying a concealed firearm on private property unless the private property owner is aware that they're carrying it and doesn't want them to have it.
Unknown Speaker• -
that's the way the law works
Unknown Speaker• -
there is no state mandated sign at this point that California has approved to go in the window of a store to say that you cannot carry a firearm other states do have them but California does not
Unknown Speaker• -
this is an example of one sign when I was doing the research
Unknown Speaker• -
there were on this one side alone where I grabbed this
Unknown Speaker• -
there were 30 different iterations of this sign that people can get and put in their windows the cost of the sign varies
Unknown Speaker• -
if we were to add any kind of or require them to add any kind of language to it I believe this sign was $12 a sign and they go up to $20 depending on what the language is on the sign
if a person is found to have a concealed weapon and the business owner does not want them to be on the property they're not in violation of any firearms laws the business owner then tells them I don't want you on my property you can either go to your car, lock up the gun in an approved situation you can take it home and lock it up and come back or you can leave the premises if the person says well I don't want to leave and I have a second amendment right to carry this gun you do, but not on private property
Unknown Speaker• -
and at that point we would trespass that person and ask them to leave now that trespassing would also in Monterey Park's case lead to a kind of an administrative hearing of the CCW permit
Unknown Speaker• -
and there's more than likely we would then pull that permit from that person
Unknown Speaker• -
if that kind of interaction were to occur and we were aware of it.
Unknown Speaker• -
But the caveat there is that the business owner has to know the person is carrying the weapon in the first place. Sometimes if they're carrying it concealed like the law says, technically you won't see it because it's concealed. So there's a little bit of a back and forth there that people would have to kind of navigate. I think SB2 will probably pass. There will be challenges to SB2 by the National Rifles Association and California associations that handle Second Amendment items. But we'll have to wait and see.
Unknown Speaker• -
And I think that's it.
I welcome any questions.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
Thank you, Chief, for that information.
Unknown Speaker• -
Any questions or comments?
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
I have a question for Carl. we got ahead of some of these things by our actions
Unknown Speaker• -
couple of meetings, correct? Go back to the slide with the list, please. There you go. Correct.
Unknown Speaker• -
Any other questions or comments? Yes, Mr. Mayor. Thank you.
Council Member Henry Lo• -
Thank you. Again, I'm very excited that we are establishing this resource page for our residents. Do we plan to also maybe do some workshops, like in-person workshops or online on some of the topics we're covering for the community?
Unknown Speaker• -
Definitely.
Unknown Speaker• -
When I have one, when SB2 passes, we're going to dive deep into SB2, the final bill, when
Unknown Speaker• -
it's actually made a law.
Unknown Speaker• -
Okay. We'll be able to kind of take it apart and define it and be able to kind of communicate with the community about what that means. we don't have any workshops planned at this point but there's no reason why we wouldn't do them
Unknown Speaker• -
we just have to kind of drill down our local law drill down the state laws and see how they would
Unknown Speaker• -
apply to the public all of our ccw holders when they are given their permits and explained the
Unknown Speaker• -
liability that goes along with the permit and they're explained the liability by three of us
Unknown Speaker• -
by the range safety officer that tests them, by the lieutenant who does the background on them,
Unknown Speaker• -
and by me personally, we talk about the liability that goes along with them having a CCW.
Unknown Speaker• -
I have not had anybody say, here it is, I'm going to give it back because of that. But we do explain to them that the laws are very restrictive, and the likelihood that they're going to be in a situation to pull that gun out has to be very, very specific. And there's a chance that without the extensive training that a police officer gets, that they may make a mistake. And that's part of the process. But all of them are aware of these sections that are coming down the line. And we will constantly keep them updated so that they understand it and they also know where the line is drawn with them. The state is going to basically restrict firearms carry for concealed carry people
Unknown Speaker• -
other than peace officers to public streets. And that's just about it. Your car, your home, your business, and that's it. Great, thank you. Mayor Pertumwang? Thanks, Chief. We appreciate this.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
I was going to save this for the second reading for some of the items coming back,
Unknown Speaker• -
but maybe we can save some time.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
You mentioned some signage. Are we planning or are we looking into assuming the ordinance has passed today? Are we looking at, or is your department looking at signage for city facilities that prohibit gun carrying?
Unknown Speaker• -
Yes, we would be looking at that.
Unknown Speaker• -
We would be looking at that for both city facilities and parks.
Unknown Speaker• -
We're in the process of, we're waiting for the immunity code to be, just like all the signs you see for parking and all those things,
Unknown Speaker• -
we list a municipal code with a police department number.
Unknown Speaker• -
we'll have to mock up a sign and make sure that it passes muster before we post it.
Unknown Speaker• -
But, yeah, we will have signs in city facilities and city parks. Perfect.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
And the more timely we can get those signs posted, I think, the better, assuming we pass the ordinance tonight. And you kind of mentioned it, if there's an opportunity to provide signage or to provide templates for signage for business owners and others. to provide signage or to provide templates for signage for business owners and others who want to also
Unknown Speaker• -
! We're prepared to do that right now. You don't have to purchase that sign from a business. You could print it ! Print it on a color printer and put it up in your window. So there virtually is no cost to the property owner if they want to post those signs. We're there to help them navigate that and explain it to them. Again, the sign is not, there's no statute that backs the sign up. there's no statute that backs the sign up. So you can put the sign in your window. The CCW holder at this point can ignore it. And if you don't see the gun, then you don't call the police and the process doesn't happen. It all depends on the signs kind of a warning that if we catch you with it, we're going to kick you out or tell you not to have it. There are some venues that are big venues in L.A., which even off-duty peace officers can't carry firearms in. So private property is private property, and you can control what happens on that private property. So we will help business owners with that and give them direction within the law that currently exists, and then we'll update them and update the community if and when that law passes.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
Yeah, that's great, and I appreciate that we're watching what L.A. County is going to do and how they're going to roll out their outreach kind of campaign on GVROs
Unknown Speaker• -
and these other gun control ordinances.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
the more we can dovetail and connect with those efforts I think would be great and if there are other efforts that we should be looking at specifically here for Monterey Park to get the word out and to do outreach right the law is only as good as people actually know it exists to enforce it or to actually call it out right so the more we can do outreach I don't know if this is this makes sense or is appropriate but I know right every every business has to come in for a business license, including some sort of material in there around their opportunity as business owners to restrict gun carrying weapons, you know, their stores, some sort of education or pamphlet or whatever for people coming in for business licenses every year and including that as part of their packet would be, I think would be helpful promoting this, assuming the ordinances pass tonight, promoting some of these efforts in Cascades and other avenues
Unknown Speaker• -
I think would be great too.
Unknown Speaker• -
Okay.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
And then adding on to what Mayor Pro Tem Wong said, if there's any way we can maybe even contact businesses using the MPK Rewards app, that they could potentially, I don't know, maybe even a way to download and print out as simple as a color printer, that would be great. I did want to piggyback on what Council Member Lo said regarding education. and I think it's very important that as we move forward with these ordinances that we're passing within the city to obviously prevent gun violence here. I want to know if we are thinking about potentially partnering with maybe just kind of like the library does with local school districts to be able to do some type of education, maybe even having a booth at their back-to-school nights with information about safe storage and handling of weapons. We know that a lot of the gun violence that happens at schools or among children usually comes from weapons that parents have at home to make sure that parents are getting this information, not just from our city, but from a different venue that they visit often, which is their schools.
Unknown Speaker• -
Absolutely. Children are considered restricted users. Right.
Unknown Speaker• -
So there are already pretty extensive state laws that prohibit firearms in homes where children are present from being unsecured.
Unknown Speaker• -
So there's already a violation present there. If the child is injured or someone else is injured because of that, it's a felony.
Unknown Speaker• -
So there's some teeth in those laws. But we would absolutely partner with the four school districts in our area and the library and get that information out.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
I think that would be great just in terms of doing, you know, almost like parent education classes, but being able to share that information with parents so that, you know, households that do have weapons are properly storing them and keeping them away from kids.
Unknown Speaker• -
We'll put together some posts, some Instagram posts and stuff. The school district is very good about capturing those that we put out and putting them out to there.
Unknown Speaker• -
And their social media access is very extensive.
Unknown Speaker• -
A lot of their parents subscribe to that, as you probably do. Yeah.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you so much, Chief.
Unknown Speaker• -
No problem. Thank you. Thank you.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
We'll go ahead and, seeing there's no more presentations, jump into item 2A, Old Business. discussion of city council stance on amended Senate Bill SB 710 by Senator Durazzo.
Unknown Speaker• -
City manager, is there?
Unknown Speaker• -
Yes. Good evening, Mr. Mayor, members of the council.
Inez Alvarez• -
This item tonight is regarding SB 710. It's before you tonight as requested by city council for discussion and consideration. At the city council meeting on April 5th, 2023, the City Council expressed opposition to SB 710. The City Council in general felt that there was a lack of representation of all the cities impacted by traffic concerns, including the City of Monterey Park. The City of Monterey Park, along with other neighboring cities, sent opposition letters regarding SB 710 as originally drafted. Since then, Senator DeRazzo amended SB 710 and the updated bill language is attached to the staff report for reference. As of when the staff report was prepared, the cities of Alhambra, Los Angeles, and Pasadena are now supporting SB 710 as amended. In August, the city received a letter from Senator Durazzo requesting the city council consider removing opposition and moving to support of the bill. That letter is also attached to the staff report for reference. this concludes my report and staff is requesting city council to provide direction regarding the city's stance on the amended language of SB 710 and if desirable direct staff to send a letter stating the city's continued opposition or support or take other action as desirable thank you
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
thank you city manager are there any questions or comments regarding SB 710 from council
Unknown Speaker• -
Council Member Lo?
Unknown Speaker• -
Yes. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Question.
Council Member Henry Lo• -
The copy of the bill that we have on the agenda, is that the latest version of the bill? Because I know some lines have been stricken, which I'm assuming is because of amendments taken up by the author.
Unknown Speaker• -
Correct. This is the amended language.
Unknown Speaker• -
I see.
Unknown Speaker• -
Any other questions or comments? Council Member Lo?
Unknown Speaker• -
Yeah, I'll start.
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
We were in Sacramento a few months ago, and we went to their office, and we specifically asked to be included, to have an active voice in either the committee or panel, and we have not heard anything. I understand why the state of Alhambra, Los Angeles, and Pasadena have changed their opinion on the bill, because they got what they wanted. From my standpoint, the city of Mario Park continues to have no representation here, so I'm going to stay silent. That's where I stand here.
Unknown Speaker• -
Until we have representation, I cannot, in my mind, support something that affects our city,
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
but we have no control, no voice over it. So that's where I feel on this.
Unknown Speaker• -
Mayor Portempo?
Unknown Speaker• -
I just echo kind of those sentiments.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
I support my understanding is right. A lot of the concerns from our neighboring city of Alhambra were addressed in amendments to the bill.
Unknown Speaker• -
And those seem like they would take away some of our most, our main concerns as well.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
in terms of the body being formed here, whatever it is, being focused on advising on potential solutions and uses for the land there in the existing corridor. So in that sense, there's no direct impact on us in and of itself that they're able to do, but also no benefit to the city, and so would be amenable to moving to a neutral position
Unknown Speaker• -
given some of the changes to the existing bill,
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
but not seeing a reason for us to explicitly support the bill unless I'm missing something.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you. Any other comments? Yes, Mr. Ryer. Council Member Lo?
Unknown Speaker• -
Yes. Thank you, Mr. Ryer.
Council Member Henry Lo• -
Again, the reason why I asked if this is the latest version of the bill is because, again, thank my colleagues for your comments, But yeah, I mean, I look at the language in this list.
Unknown Speaker• -
Two representatives from the city of Longhambra. Two representatives from the city of Los Angeles.
Council Member Henry Lo• -
One who resides in 90032 zip code. One representative from the county of Los Angeles. One representative from California State University of Los Angeles. One representative from Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority. One representative from a business or workforce entity. One representative from a community-based organization. And let's see, no more than two additional members to be appointed by a department.
Unknown Speaker• -
And, you know, my concern is that, you know,
Council Member Henry Lo• -
One is only looking at a map of Monterey Park, and it's very clear that the terminus, part of the terminus is in our boundaries. And I find interesting that the author is willing to include part of the county of L.A., because I know there is unincorporated Los Angeles west of us, but not us. And so I would say I don't see a need for it to take action to change our position, to be honest.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
Thank you, Council Member Lo. I'd also like to echo the same sentiments of the other council members. Frankly, kind of offended that we're not included in this. In particular, the district that I represent, District 3, would be potentially dramatically impacted by anything that happens in this corridor. So I think that Monterey Park not only deserves a spot on this commission as part of this group, but also I think we have a vested interest to ensure that whatever happens in this corridor falls within the benefits of the residents of Monterey Park. It doesn't dramatically impact it. We are already impacted by heavy traffic because of the 60 freeway and the 710 corridor and the 10 freeway. Our city resides within the borders of all these freeways, and so whatever happens in this section of the 710 freeway will obviously dramatically impact the residents of Monterey Park. especially those that I represent in District 3. So I also do not see any reason why we should support SB 710. I also would encourage us to, as a council, to send a letter back to Senator Durazzo expressing our sentiments and feelings about this and request that we be offered a seat or two on this commission as well. But I see no reason to change our position. In fact, I would probably even argue in opposition, but just to be fair and give Senator Durazo an opportunity to respond, I would say stay neutral on this and not support it.
Unknown Speaker• -
Councilmember, you?
Unknown Speaker• -
I just wanted to, yeah, I mean, follow the sentiment.
Unknown Speaker• -
Yeah, when we opposed in the beginning, we want a voice.
Unknown Speaker• -
And now with the changes, I don't see that they give us what we want.
Unknown Speaker• -
And I don't know why we wanted to change it from opposed to agree.
Unknown Speaker• -
There's no reason. So I will say continue to oppose the bill.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
So just to clarify, the position of the city is already to oppose. We're talking about if we want to change our position. So there's no action if we want to continue with that position, right?
Unknown Speaker• -
Correct.
Inez Alvarez• -
We do not have to take any action if that's the council's desire. if the council is looking to send a letter though about requesting a seat on the task force. I'm not sure if that's the, I heard a comment. I'm not sure if that is something that the council would like to consider or it's just no action.
Unknown Speaker• -
I know, I mean, this is my very quick thoughts, right?
Unknown Speaker• -
There's a week and a half left in the legislative session, right?
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
We won't have another council meeting to suss out what might happen or if there are any amendments to the bill, good or bad for us. My feeling is to provide authorization to the mayor at his flexibility and depending on what happens these next few days, since the council probably won't meet before this bill is finalized one way or the other,
Unknown Speaker• -
just to give him a broad authority to issue a letter if he sees fit,
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
given where it's at, or to, I don't know, express a different opinion if the bill changes in one way or another towards our...
Unknown Speaker• -
And to add to what the Mayor Pro Temp said, and he's correct,
Unknown Speaker• -
session ends on the 14th of September.
Unknown Speaker• -
In fact, I mean, given this bill is probably already in the Assembly,
Unknown Speaker• -
I mean, it may have already been voted on or will be voted on. So I do agree.
Council Member Henry Lo• -
Yeah, I mean, perhaps, you know, empower the mayor to see fit, you know, how he wants to respond.
Unknown Speaker• -
But I mean, at this point, yeah, I mean, the bill is probably somewhere moving its way through the docket of the assembly.
Council Member Henry Lo• -
And so, I mean, when does, when does this request came from the senator's office regarding our position change or ask us what this came?
Unknown Speaker• -
Let's see.
Inez Alvarez• -
We received the letter, or the letter is dated August 7th.
Unknown Speaker• -
Okay, I see.
Unknown Speaker• -
So probably because at that point it may have gone, we'll still go into committee.
Unknown Speaker• -
So I mean, I mean, again, again, I just wondered,
Unknown Speaker• -
you know, this late in the day, you know,
I think our positions are made clear from the beginning. And, you know, I think perhaps had we acted sooner,
Council Member Henry Lo• -
maybe a bit of consequence to the senator's office. But again, given that it was August 7th, it's now September 6th,
Unknown Speaker• -
again, it probably is already going through the daily file as we speak.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
Well, I think for the time being, what I'm hearing is we could... I think for the time being what I'm hearing is we could maintain our opposition position without
Unknown Speaker• -
!
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
having any votes and then following up with a letter about our status and the need for a seat on the task force.
Unknown Speaker• -
Is that what I'm hearing?
Unknown Speaker• -
I think I'm amenable to the mayor if the mayor feels the need to issue a letter in the remaining week and a half
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
or so of the session to make our concerns that were made clear tonight clear to the senator and the legislature. made clear tonight, clear to the Senator and the legislature, I think that authority should be there for the Mayor to do so in the next week and a half.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
Well, thank you, and then we'll keep you updated.
We'll go ahead and jump to consent calendar items 3A through 3Q.
Unknown Speaker• -
Are there any items that Council would like pulled for discussion or reports?
Unknown Speaker• -
3d and 3e 3d and 3e any other ones I will pull 3b 3f 3n
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
AND THEN I BELIEVE I NEED TO RECUSE ON 3P SINCE SOME OF THE PROJECTS ARE WITHIN 500 FEET OF MY PROPERTY.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
OKAY. SO CAN I, IS THERE A MOTION THEN TO PASS ITEMS, THE REMAINING ITEMS, 3A, 3C, 3G, H, I, J, K, L, M.
City Clerk Maychelle Yee• -
I HAVE ONE COMMENT FOR 3L.
Unknown Speaker• -
OPQ.
City Clerk Maychelle Yee• -
One speaker for 3L.
Unknown Speaker• -
Okay. One public.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
That one's being pulled.
Unknown Speaker• -
Okay. We'll hear a comment now.
Nancy Okurie.
Unknown Speaker• -
Good evening again. I'm very happy to see this project on North New Avenue get the one-year extension,
Unknown Speaker• -
finally moving forward as this lot has been vacant for many years.
Unknown Speaker• -
When the New Avenue school was located there,
Unknown Speaker• -
I noticed there was heavy traffic backed up on the left lane on New Avenue as many of the parents had to wait for break and traffic to enter the schoolyard.
Unknown Speaker• -
So I want to know what this developer will be doing to prevent this issue from happening again. Thank you.
Unknown Speaker• -
Okay. Thank you. No other speakers. No other speakers. Okay.
Unknown Speaker• -
Is there a motion?
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
I'll make the motion to approve everything except for the pool items.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you. Is there a second? Second. Seconded by Council Member Lo. And if we can take a vote, please.
Unknown Speaker• -
Approved unanimously.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
We'll go ahead and jump to item 3B and I know several Council members, I'm sorry, Mayor
Unknown Speaker• -
Potem Wong pulled this. Do you like an abbreviated or?
Unknown Speaker• -
Abbreviated. Abbreviated staff report. Sure.
Unknown Speaker• -
Good evening again, Mr. Mayor, members of the City Council.
Inez Alvarez• -
This item again is brought forward tonight at the request of City Council. The Behavior Health Modernization Package includes two bills aimed at addressing behavioral health crisis and providing better care and support to those in need. SB 326 seeks to modernize the Mental Health Services Act by expanding services to include treatment for substance use disorders
Unknown Speaker• -
and focus on accountability outcomes and equity. AB 531 proposes a significant $4.68 billion
Inez Alvarez• -
general obligation bond on the March 2024 ballot to create 10,000 new treatment beds and housing units offering housing and care to individuals experiencing homelessness with behavioral health needs. City Council has requested to consider authorizing the Mayor to sign letters of support for California Senate Bill 326 and Assembly Bill 531 addressing mental and behavioral health services. That concludes my report.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
Any questions or comments from council?
Unknown Speaker• -
Mayor for 10 long. I know you think I didn't thank you to the staff for putting this together
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
And I just want to say up front that I wholly support the intent behind these and then providing resources for mental health right beds and housing and there's obviously a need and For us here in our own community. I need to address homelessness and mental health issues that intersect in a lot of ways in our own community. I just want to make sure if we haven't, or if anyone knows, if LA County has a position on this, I know and I've heard that there are concerns from some counties and mental health providers around at least part of this bill in terms of redirecting existing funding for mental health funds and services to this specific purpose, and there are concerns around the loss of funding for some existing programming. I wouldn't want to get in the way, I don't want to support something that's going to take away from services that we still need to provide for other services that are in need of resources too, and if there's a way to check in on that. And also knowing, given our just recent discussion, that the legislative session is about to end and that these bills are going to be,
Unknown Speaker• -
from the news reading,
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
it looks like these are very likely to pass, but knowing that we won't have another councilman to go through this, I just wanted to see if there's any information on where the counties are or even CSC or others that provide mental health services, if any of their funding might be impacted by this potential change in funding at the state level.
Unknown Speaker• -
I don't believe that we have any information of whether LA County
Inez Alvarez• -
or even CSC has supported these items or opposed them.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
I'm happy to make the motion or to let someone else make a motion on authorizing the mayor when I would suggest all council members signatures beyond this letter but authorizing that action to happen to sign on in support of these bills if we can do a quick check and if we do find that LA County or other mental health service providers that the city partners with have serious concerns about these bills that maybe we don't exercise that authority. I don't know if that, does that work, Carl, or I don't know how that works.
Unknown Speaker• -
Okay. Council Member, you? Yeah, I just have a question that for AB 531 proposed a significant 4.68 billion
Unknown Speaker• -
geo bonds on March 2024.
Unknown Speaker• -
I'm wondering that if they're issuing the geo bond at the highest interest rates, what would be the interest rate? And that would be a very significant debt to create it for the state.
Unknown Speaker• -
So I'm just wondering what the interest rate would be. And that is actually the, I don't want to say it's the wrong timing, but it's like the highest interest rate ever.
Unknown Speaker• -
And then when you issue bonds, it can be given out so much interest at the time.
Unknown Speaker• -
Then I don't know if the timing is right here.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
I believe the bill would authorize the state to issue those bonds. It doesn't require them to do it at a certain point. right they have flexibility to determine if I'm not that interest rates are come down to where they were a few years ago very likely anytime soon but they don't have to write the day that it passes they're not buying the bonds there's
Unknown Speaker• -
flexibility there in terms of financing period but I don't know that's yeah
Unknown Speaker• -
Councilmember Ngo?
Unknown Speaker• -
I hear
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
Councilman Yu's concerns
Unknown Speaker• -
however
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
in this situation it's going to get voter approved in March I don't know how long it's going to take for the
Unknown Speaker• -
bonds to get issued
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
I think where I stand on this is
Unknown Speaker• -
I'd like the suggestion made by Pro Tem Wong
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
which is let's figure out LA County which we're part of if they're supportive of this I think deep inside we support this mental health aspect of this. The bond issue is another story another discussion hopefully later versus sooner based on the bond market and interest rates. In any case if the state approves it they're gonna find a way to
Unknown Speaker• -
do it. So I mean I'd be happy to make the recommendation or did Pro Tem Wong
Unknown Speaker• -
already make a recommendation I'll second that. That sounds great. Are there any other questions or comments? All right if we can take a vote please.
Unknown Speaker• -
Approved unanimously. Thank you. If staff can just report back on what we ultimately do on this one that would be helpful. Thank you. And we did say to put
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
all the council members signatures right now. Okay. Okay. Excellent. And then item 3D.
Unknown Speaker• -
Council member, you, you pulled item 3D. Would you like a report, abbreviated report?
Good evening, Council. My name is Amy Lee, City Treasurer for Marnier Park. The City Investment Policy requires an annual investment report and a statement of investment policy we submitted to the City Council for annual review.
Unknown Speaker• -
The attached annual report shows all the investment activities for 2022-2023 that they were conducted according to the city's investment policy for that year. The total investment balance for the city of Barnard Park as of June 30, 2023 was $87,909.153. The Treasury Committee is introducing and recommending the adoption of the attached investment policy. The investment policy includes the most recent government citations as amended by Senate Bill 998 and 1489. It allows the Treasury Committee to diversify the city's portfolio while continuing to prioritize safety, liquidity, and yield. The city, together with the Treasury Committee, has contracted Chandler Asset Management to assist with the development of the investment policy.
Unknown Speaker• -
We have worked on it and has been reviewed by Chandler, and they are here today to have a presentation for you.
Unknown Speaker• -
Today we have Mia Corral Brown, a regional director for Chandler, and Kara Hooks, an associate portfolio strategist at Chandler.
Unknown Speaker• -
Mia Brown has over 20 years of experience servicing the municipalities,
Unknown Speaker• -
and Carol Hooks is an associate portfolio strategist.
Unknown Speaker• -
Her specialty is on key investment themes and trends for implementation into the local government
Unknown Speaker• -
and additional client portfolios. I'll let them speak on the investment policy.
Thank you, Amy, and good evening, honorary mayor, mayor pro tem, and members of the city council. Thank you for inviting us to be here this evening. In late spring, early summer, we were contacted by finance staff and City Treasurer Amy Lee to conduct a thorough review and analysis of the city's investment policy. One of the things that we wanted to do was to provide Chandler's model policy to the city for consideration and adoption. What this does is it elevates the city's investment program, provides and incorporates all of the language that is set forth per California government state code, and will allow the city to submit their investment policy, if adopted, to the California Municipal Treasurers Association for annual certification. as Amy mentioned I'm a regional director at Chandler Asset Management I've been at the firm for 19 years but I've brought an investment specialist with me this evening, Kara Hooks and Kara outlined and redlined the investment policy for submission to the finance committee and we have a very brief presentation that we will go through to just highlight some of those key changes if you will. So with that
Unknown Speaker• -
I'm going to invite care up. I'm a bit taller. There we go. So on this next page that we have, what we've done first is we want to highlight first the full investment universe that the city is alLod by California government code to invest within. So what you see listed there is everything in the investment universe. So these are things that individuals would be able to invest in in their own portfolios, whereas now if you look at the top green area where it says short duration fixed income and code status on the far right alLod, those are the very narrow parameters that the city is permitted to invest within within California government code. And then within those parameters, you'll see in the investment policy, we further refine and restrict allowable investments in order to ensure the city's objectives of safety, liquidity, and yield. On the following slide, you'll see some of our higher observations.
Unknown Speaker• -
The main items that we have is we'd like to include the Senate Bills 998 and 1489.
Unknown Speaker• -
Senate Bill 998 includes no more than 10% of commercial paper in corporates of any single issuer may be purchased, as well as zero or negative interest accrual securities, but that was mainly implemented during the pandemic.
Unknown Speaker• -
includes is it changes allowable days to settlement and that generally involves municipal bonds. And then 45 days to submit a quarterly report opposed to 30 days. And then lastly it changes the settlement date as opposed to the trade date for when maturity is established, changing
Unknown Speaker• -
it by just a few days there. Other items really to allow for greater diversification that we see there is we like to expand the authorized investments to include money market mutual funds, supernationals, and pass-through securities, inclusive of asset-backed securities and mortgage-backed securities. We'd also like to adjust the maximum percentages alLod per investment type and issuer.
Unknown Speaker• -
There might be, one example would be federal agencies, where in the California government code there is no limit as to what you can invest in. However, we find it is a best interest and a good industry practice to instill a limit there. So you'll find that we'll further refine California government code to further ensure safety.
Unknown Speaker• -
One other area that we'd like to highlight is you'd like to note that the city would explore the potential to engage with an external investment advisor.
Unknown Speaker• -
You'd want to add just some language in there stating this potential availability for the city. And then that would further establish some other areas within the investment policy, namely like if there's broker-dealers, we would use our specific broker-dealers that we've contracted with
Unknown Speaker• -
essentially after we do review with them.
Unknown Speaker• -
On the following page, you'll see here. So overall, what these recommendations would do, as Mia had mentioned, is that they'll allow an external investment advisor to have access to all investments as described in California Government Code 53601. It would also provide city staff with an investment policy that can be submitted to CMTA, as Mia had mentioned and then also create the groundwork to truly employ an investment strategy to optimize returns for longer-term projects and Resources for the city and with that we'd like to take any questions
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you any questions or comments from Council
Unknown Speaker• -
Council member you yeah, thank you so much for clarify and so I think it's good to review our investment policy has been outdated for quite some time. And I think that leads to your next presentations about your investment allocation.
Unknown Speaker• -
So, yeah, thank you so much for reviewing our
Unknown Speaker• -
investment policy. Thank you. Very welcome.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you. Any other questions or comments? Mayor Potemwong? Thank you. I appreciate the
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
work and staff and the consultants in terms of looking at expanding our options for what we can do to invest and make sure that we're yielding a return. For some of the, when I was looking through the investment, the proposed investment policy, I'm just curious, I don't, I'm not personally familiar with some of these assets. Are any of these, do any of these carry a risk of loss for the principal?
Unknown Speaker• -
So our ultimate goal is principal preservation.
Unknown Speaker• -
So with our research done by our team, that would be if we were to be managed.
Unknown Speaker• -
There would be minimal loss.
Unknown Speaker• -
However, when you're investing, there's always a potential for loss.
Unknown Speaker• -
But ideally, when purchasing bonds, though, if you're holding to maturity, you are never truly losing what you are purchasing.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
Yeah, I'm particularly looking at asset-backed, mortgage-backed, mortgage-passed securities, collateralized mortgage obligations. funds, my understanding of money market mutual funds are that those are pretty much guaranteed.
Unknown Speaker• -
Those are guaranteed.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
But I'm not, these asset-backed and mortgage-backed securities sound like, just remind me of the 2008 financial crisis.
Unknown Speaker• -
Yes.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
And significant losses that occurred there. I'm really worried about this potentially, the risk there in terms of, and potentially and other assets that we might invest in if this policy passes that might incur losses to our principal?
Unknown Speaker• -
That's a great question. And also a common concern when we are presenting these types of updates to cities who haven't done these types of updates. A lot of them ended up putting pass-throughs in the prohibited section following what occurred in the early 2000s. And so one thing to notice if Chandler were to be the ones investing on your behalf is the asset-backed securities that we purchase. are of the high grade, the higher end of those, the higher tranche. So very safe. They tend to be the ones that get paid back first. And so we're not going to be buying the ones from, say, an asset-backed security where it is backed by car loans and the individuals have a higher loan rate or a longer-term period. We want to have the money returned quickly. And with mortgages like CMOs or MBS,
Unknown Speaker• -
We are looking to purchase the ones that get paid back the quickest with the highest level of safety in there.
Unknown Speaker• -
So we are also doing our due diligence within those. So you are opening yourself up.
Unknown Speaker• -
I mean, more options there is better diversification. But, you know, with investment does come some risk. However, per California government code, you are very limited to how risky you can really be.
Unknown Speaker• -
Yeah, it sounds like you. If I may just add, these are all highly rated A or better fixed income securities, and we will really be conducting very in-depth credit analysis. But I do want to make the point that the city currently invests with LEIF and LASIP. And as a passive investor in both of these investment pools, The city has had exposure to all of these asset classes for over the last two decades. So we're not introducing anything that's necessarily new. What you're allowing LEIF and LASIP to do, you would just be potentially allowing an external investment advisor to do.
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
So question for me, as you stated, we're already in this game.
Unknown Speaker• -
You are.
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
and it's double a double a or better so we're basically peeling off the top tier pieces my question for you is because i'm not really familiar with your office so your group can you tell me a little bit background about your office and how much in portfolio management strategic management in the in the billions and how many full-time employees
Unknown Speaker• -
and how many regions and offices certainly so one of the things that we did this evening is prepare a presentation about Chandler Asset Management and how we might be able to partner with the City of Monterey Park. So if we can go ahead and pull that up, we'll go ahead
Unknown Speaker• -
and jump into that. Council Member, no. Do we want to go into 3DE and move off of 3D?
Unknown Speaker• -
There is a separate question. If there's a motion to approve 3D, we can move on to 3E.
Unknown Speaker• -
Motion to approve 3D. Is there a second?
Unknown Speaker• -
I'll second. I would just note that understanding that we already
Unknown Speaker• -
exposed.
Unknown Speaker• -
So can we just do both?
Unknown Speaker• -
They're both related. That's fine.
Unknown Speaker• -
We'll do three and then we'll. Thank you.
Unknown Speaker• -
If we can do the presentation.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you.
Unknown Speaker• -
We're back for part two. So the city has historically invested the majority of their funds in the local government investment pools, which are LAF and the city
Unknown Speaker• -
LAF and LA County investment pool.
Unknown Speaker• -
With rates substantially higher, the city has the opportunity now to optimize our interest earnings. We brought Chandler
Unknown Speaker• -
again. They're here to talk about what they have to offer.
Unknown Speaker• -
Chandler currently manages $27 billion in California with over $20 billion with the public agencies. So I'll give it to them to present their presentation.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you, Amy. And again, we really appreciate this opportunity to be here this evening
Unknown Speaker• -
and to present our qualifications to potentially partner with the City of Monterey Park.
Unknown Speaker• -
So let's go ahead and advance a slide, please. One more. Again.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you. And this is really just introducing our engagement team. So again, I'm Mia Correll-Brown, a regional director at Chandler.
Unknown Speaker• -
And for almost the last two decades, I've had the pleasure of serving as an institutional client service and public sector specialist, working with public agencies throughout Southern California. With me again today is Kara Hooks.
Unknown Speaker• -
Kara is a portfolio strategist, which is essentially a client-facing portfolio manager. Also pictured here is Jason Schmidt. Jason has been at Chandler for over 25 years and has almost three decades of industry experience. If we were fortunate enough to be selected to manage a portion of the portfolio for the city of Monterey Park, Jason would lead the implementation of the investment strategy on your behalf.
Unknown Speaker• -
We also have pictured here to the right Stacy Alderson, and Stacy is a client service director. She will oversee the onboarding and work very closely with me and our team in order to ensure that we provide a very seamless experience to the city of Monterey Park.
Unknown Speaker• -
Next slide, please.
Unknown Speaker• -
So this to address Mayor Pro Tem Wong's question and some of the concerns of council. Chandler Asset Management was founded 35 years ago by Kay Chandler.
Unknown Speaker• -
And Kay, in the early part of her career, served as an investment officer first for the county of San Diego,
Unknown Speaker• -
folLod by the city. And she was often called upon by agencies like, or associations rather, like CMTA, GFOA, which is the Government Finance Officers Association, and CSMFO to provide technical training and expertise.
Unknown Speaker• -
And one of the key observations she had back then was that there was not a local California-based public sector investment advisory firm. So with that, she set out to open our doors. Today, well, this is as of 630. We have $33.3 billion in assets. But as of today's reading, we are approaching $35 billion in assets.
Unknown Speaker• -
all shared for clients who share very similar objectives to the city of Monterey Park
Unknown Speaker• -
for safety, liquidity, and last but not least, return. Our goal at Chandler is to provide customized investment programs for public sector clients. And as you can see to the left, over 86% of the assets that we manage are for public agencies, many of whom are here in our home state of California. The other assets that are managed are for health care or for private individuals who have the very same objectives of safety, liquidity, and return. I think it's important to note that Chandler is an independent firm, and we are employee-owned.
Unknown Speaker• -
We do not have any ties to brokerage, banking, or financial advisory services.
Unknown Speaker• -
We are a registered investment advisor, and as such, we serve as a co-fiduciary of the assets that we will manage on your behalf. We have a very stable team of investment professionals. Each of our portfolio managers have earned the designation of Chartered Financial Analyst, and we have a team that has been in place through various market cycles, especially at the upper end with our senior team and investment members. One of the benefits of working with us is the access. Martha and Amy can attest that they have had the ability to meet several of the employees at Chandler and benefit from direct access via phone and or email to the professionals at our firm. We currently have 42 employees, and if we were selected, your portfolio would be managed and serviced from our headquarters in North San Diego. Next slide, please.
Unknown Speaker• -
I think it's important to note that we have a significant amount of experience managing portfolios for many of your neighbors and peers. What I did here is just pull together a snapshot of some of our neighboring clients for whom we've been able to provide investment management services. These are all existing clients, and we have very longstanding relationships with all of them. When you look at the LA cities here, we have been working with the city of El Monte, Pomona, also in the San Gabriel Valley, Walnut Valley Water District for, gosh, over 15 years, Upper San Gabriel Municipal Water District located right down the road on Foothill, as well as the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation System, the bus system, essentially, that runs through this area. We also have very large clients, such as the city of Beverly Hills. When you look to the inland area clients, large, really large entities, almost a billion dollars, include the city of Riverside, city of Palm Springs, and many others. So we work with not only municipalities, but water districts and counties and special districts. Again, looking to Orange County. in Orange County, we manage portfolios for over 22 public agencies within Orange. So I'll go ahead and continue on to the next slide, please. And we'll ask Akira to come up to talk to you a little bit about the investment strategies that fit well with our California public agencies.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you, Mia. So what you see here is really how we like to think of the city's total portfolio.
Unknown Speaker• -
So when designing an investment program, we want to think of that main top gray bar, the total items.
Unknown Speaker• -
So on the far left, you have the checking account. Those are your daily expenditures.
Unknown Speaker• -
That will be items that are needed for daily liquidity. In the middle item here, you'll see the liquidity.
the far right you'll see greater than one year. So we're expecting for those funds those will be the ones that Chandler will step in and manage on your behalf. And what we expect for those funds is really for them not to be needed for more than a year. That way we could truly put an investment program to work for you. With these they would be invested in either a limited maturity strategy or a short-term strategy and we'll look at those on the next page. And really we'll target that longer duration to enhance the potential earnings income. If we move to the next slide, what you'll see here are two different composites that Chandler has that are used by many of the entities Mia listed earlier in the presentation. On the left-hand side, you'll see the limited maturity, and this is really a step up from LEIF or LGIP's investment. So this is a one-to-three-year strategy. You'll see the average duration is set at 1.6 years, and then further down with the maturity distribution, we have a heavy allotment to the zero to one years and then almost 50 percent in the one to three years and then the remainder in three to five. On the right hand side you'll see the short-term bond which is the one to five year and this is really this will have more volatility as it will have a higher duration of 2.34 years. Now duration is really your measurement to risk and that would be the primary focus for Chandler is we're going to really measure the duration instead of trying to chase yield. So in good times we'll stick to the duration and in bad times we'll stick to the duration. Now whether that means we go under or over the benchmark duration really just depends as to what our research teams are seeing. You'll see the maturity distribution but really what I want to point out down below is the sector allocation. So the diversification in both of
Unknown Speaker• -
these portfolios have a heavy use of U.S. treasuries and agencies and corporates and then you'll see some inclusion of super nationals as well as CMOs. We're finding a lot of use in CMOs as they're relatively safe and are being issued a bit frequently now.
Unknown Speaker• -
So as I mentioned, these are the primary options that your fellow constituents or your fellow cities have used. And so we would really recommend them to be, you know, one to three as the safer option, the step up. Whereas if you're willing to have that higher volatility potentially have some losses, but that would be realized, but not without those being calculated into future purchases. So we wouldn't ever sell a security without ensuring that the purchase we'll make in its steed would outweigh that loss, essentially. On the following page, what you'll see here is the two benchmarks that we use against these strategies. We have LAFE, which is essentially the city's current strategy, and then we have the ISP of A 1-3-year U.S. Treasury Index and then the 1-5-year Treasury and Agency Index. So the 1-3 would be the limited option and then the 1-5 would be the short-term bond security. Now, these are the benchmark information and down below you'll see with a value on 630-2023 of $40 million invested 20 years earlier, you can see the annualized returns and the difference between the three different strategies there. Now, these are the benchmarks. So really, let's compare to the strategies that we have on the following page.
Unknown Speaker• -
So the strategy information listed here, you'll see LEIF across the top. Really what this is showing, and as we have talked to the city for a decade now, this would show what happened if the city would have invested 20 years ago. So if the city would have invested $40 million 20 years ago, you'll see that the LEIF amount would come to $54.6 million. Now, if it had been within the Chandler Limited Maturity Composite, it would have been $58.5 million, so an additional $3.9 million.
Unknown Speaker• -
If you would have taken that additional risk of a longer duration, then you would have had an additional $6.8 million for a total of $61.4 million.
Unknown Speaker• -
Really think of that as more funds to put towards the city's needs and any future projects that you would be planning. On the following page, you'll see truly how we approach to build an optimal investment program.
Unknown Speaker• -
So review of an investment policy, we can check that box as we've conducted that. That would be something that we do on an annual basis with all of our clients.
Unknown Speaker• -
Next, we do a cash flow analysis to ensure that you're maintaining an appropriate amount of liquidity
Unknown Speaker• -
because we don't ever want you to come upon an event where you would have to draw from the investment portfolio.
Unknown Speaker• -
We'd want you to have those funds safely secure within LEIF for easy access and to minimize any potential losses.
Unknown Speaker• -
Then we would develop the portfolio strategy. We would discuss with you what your safety levels are, what staff is safe with, what you all feel safest with, and the amount of risk that you're willing to take in the portfolio. Once we have that developed, and that would be using the four pillars that we have. We take a focus for the investment team. We look at the duration that you're willing to go with. We look at the sector allocation that you want. so what's available within the investment policy. We would look at the maturity term, how long you want to go, so 1 to 3 or 1 to 5. And then we would also select the security selection, so what are you comfortable investing in?
Unknown Speaker• -
Even though we have the investment policy, that doesn't mean we have to invest necessarily in all those things immediately.
Unknown Speaker• -
We would be open to only investing in the items that we see fit at the time. So just because we have MBS in the investment policy doesn't mean that that would be one of the first things we invest in.
Unknown Speaker• -
because we want to ensure that we are doing proper due diligence when creating the city's optimum portfolio.
Unknown Speaker• -
And then within the following page, you'll see here the, oh, sorry. What I'm going to do is hand it over to Mia Corral-Brown now as she can go over the reporting types that we have for you. In light of time, I'm going to go ahead and wrap it up very quickly. But what we're wanting to show you here is that we have a very robust reporting program. so you'll receive monthly reports on the third business day as well as quarterly reports and annual reports to close your books and to create the annual comprehensive financial report as well as the GASB 72 report for fair value market measurement. And with that, we can go ahead and close and open it up to any questions.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you for that report. Any questions or comments from Council? Council Member Yu?
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you so much for the presentation. You came here about two years ago on Zoom, I remember. So I actually did research on your company. But another question, because now safety is very important to us. And may I ask, who is your broker dealer? Which broker dealer are you using?
Unknown Speaker• -
So we use a variety of broker dealers. We have over, I would say, 35 on an approved list that we interact with. And that would be to ensure that we are getting a multiple amount of quotes We have some that we use for certain types of securities that are coming to market And so on the specific list I don't have but we do evaluate our broker dealers on an annual basis To ensure that they still are providing us optimum pricing and that we can maintain a good relationship with them
Unknown Speaker• -
You said you use 35 yes
Unknown Speaker• -
Yes. So we utilize Bloomberg Aim when we go out to conduct trading because we are block trading at institutional levels with the assets that we have under management. So they are oftentimes names that you'll recognize, Merrill Lynch, Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs, but we are going straight to Wall Street in order to provide savings and not using local brokers. we provide trade tickets to show evidence of best execution and we always get three bids or offers when you go when we go out to trade on our clients behalf then where's your license holding on
Unknown Speaker• -
your license with which broker dealer our license um
Unknown Speaker• -
I can send you our CRD number but we are a registered investment advisor and each of our investment professionals are licensed.
Unknown Speaker• -
Do you have fidelity bonds and what will be the coverage? Definitely
Unknown Speaker• -
we do. The coverage is greater than $10 million and when we contract with any agency we share
Unknown Speaker• -
the COI or certificate of insurance. I'd be happy to furnish one to Martha tomorrow if you'd like to see it. But we do have a fidelity
Unknown Speaker• -
bond, we have cyber security program, disaster recovery and a privacy policy that we do share with clients. It all can be found in our ADV.
Unknown Speaker• -
Council Member Goon?
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
Just clarification, it's $27 billion in
Unknown Speaker• -
California and
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
the rest of the states or you guys operate
Unknown Speaker• -
mainly in California?
Unknown Speaker• -
We were founded in California so we do manage the vast
Unknown Speaker• -
majority of assets here in our home state and we're very proud of that. We do have clients in Colorado,
Unknown Speaker• -
Washington,
Unknown Speaker• -
an office in Florida
Unknown Speaker• -
and a sporadic amount in Utah and in the southwest.
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
So I guess that's the 33 versus the 27.
Unknown Speaker• -
Correct. Okay, I just wanted to confirm.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you. And Council Member Lo? Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
Council Member Henry Lo• -
Real quick, so I know in our staff report you listed some of our neighboring cities,
Unknown Speaker• -
the city of Pomona, the city of Amonte,
Council Member Henry Lo• -
and I know in your presentation you mentioned the upper San Diego Valley Municipal Water District. For example, for those agencies, how long have you represented them?
Unknown Speaker• -
We've probably worked with the city of El Monte for over five years. The city of Pomona is seven.
Unknown Speaker• -
I can tell you there are many clients listed in that client list. City of Brea, we've worked with since 1997.
Unknown Speaker• -
City of Newport Beach for over 30 years. Our client list is deep.
Unknown Speaker• -
We have a very strong client retention rate. It's over 95%. Clients hire us and retain us.
Unknown Speaker• -
And we really have very strong relationships with those agencies.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you. And Mayor Potempo?
Unknown Speaker• -
Thanks. I appreciate the overview for your firm. A quick question for staff more.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
Do we have an existing relationship with Chandler? And are you guys managing any assets for us currently? I'm just trying to understand the context.
Unknown Speaker• -
No. This is a new relationship we are trying to build.
Unknown Speaker• -
Okay.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
And then you guys pitched this a few years ago too?
Unknown Speaker• -
We've been pitching the city for over 15 years.
Unknown Speaker• -
So we've been out here through various financial professionals over the last decade and a half.
Unknown Speaker• -
And then for a little bit, about two years ago, when we brought Chandler, we did an RFP.
Martha Garcia• -
And we had three proposals and Chandler was the best qualified for our city.
Unknown Speaker• -
Okay.
Unknown Speaker• -
Is there any reason we didn't? I mean, obviously I was on the council.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
Was there a reason we didn't move ahead with Chandler after the RFP at that point? Or we just didn't see a need for?
Unknown Speaker• -
It was voted against by council. It was brought to council.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
Any summary of the reasoning why?
Unknown Speaker• -
I'm just curious. It wasn't the right time.
Martha Garcia• -
it wasn't the right time and now it's hopefully a better time to bring him back
Unknown Speaker• -
okay
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
and I understand the you presented the right the value statement in terms of
Unknown Speaker• -
how you over perform how you would have over performed late
Unknown Speaker• -
returns
Unknown Speaker• -
over the years I mean I would want to make
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
one I would want to make sure that going forward that's the case as well and we make sure that we do
Unknown Speaker• -
in analysis
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
net of fees and I'm looking at the fee structure
Unknown Speaker• -
some other questions on that but can you explain in very succinct language
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
and in as plain English as possible
Unknown Speaker• -
how your firm
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
returns better returns than LEIF if you're investing the same kind of assets
Unknown Speaker• -
yes so LEIF is an overnight government pool, they utilize a shorter duration. So the duration of the LEIF portfolio is shorter. We would be taking a longer duration approach, investing, as Kara said, assets greater than
Unknown Speaker• -
one year, between one and three years or one and five years. So typically the longer duration,
Unknown Speaker• -
the higher return. But there can be a little more volatility.
Unknown Speaker• -
So my question is even more pointed and succinct to Pro Tem Wong here.
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
Bottom line, what distinguishes you guys, your firm, from your competitor set? My understanding is I know it's $27 billion, $33 billion. It sounds like a big number, but it's not in this magnitude with municipality, government works. So what's your differentiator in terms of how you compete and why are these cities that have been with you three years, five years, seven years, the relationship?
Unknown Speaker• -
What's the success rate of that?
Unknown Speaker• -
I would like to answer that. It's their customer service.
Martha Garcia• -
When we interviewed the three companies, Chandler was the most prepared. They offered us a cash flow analysis even before they came and interviewed
Unknown Speaker• -
While the other two companies wanted to charge us, Chandler did not.
Martha Garcia• -
So there's a lot of, they helped us prepare a policy.
Unknown Speaker• -
So it's their customer service. I pick up the phone, they're there.
Martha Garcia• -
They also offer online services.
Unknown Speaker• -
And we have same-day, real-time activity reports of what's going on with them.
Unknown Speaker• -
So it's customer service.
Martha Garcia• -
And if you ask any other cities, they're going to say it's their customer service and responsiveness.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
On the, is there a minimum required investment amount that we would have to place with Chandler?
Unknown Speaker• -
So our account minimum is typically $25 million.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
I mean, this question is for Martha. I understand that we have like $80-something million in assets in investments right now, but our actual reserve, right, a lot of that, the bulk of that is money that's meant to be spent, right, the street bond and other water fees, water.
So most of those assets aren't sitting there for a very long time. Is that $25 million minimum, are we able to meet that, given that that's the case for most of our funds?
Martha Garcia• -
Yeah, the Treasury Committee has been meeting more regularly, and Amy, along with Ines,
Unknown Speaker• -
and our city manager and our assistant city manager, we all agree that we feel comfortable
Unknown Speaker• -
starting with $25 million because we do have so many capital projects going on.
Unknown Speaker• -
Okay.
Unknown Speaker• -
And then I don't know if Finn wants to go while I collect my thoughts. Okay.
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
So basically we got 80, but we got to keep some in LEIF and LACPIF, right? So what of that portion can we really invest? I guess that's my more direct question.
Unknown Speaker• -
Of the 50, what is it?
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
I know it's at least 25. Is that 40? Is that 50?
Unknown Speaker• -
So the last time we did a cash analysis with Chandler,
Unknown Speaker• -
which was about two years ago,
Unknown Speaker• -
was $40 million that was idle longer than a two-year period that we could use.
Unknown Speaker• -
We could, if council authorizes,
Martha Garcia• -
do another cash flow analysis to see what the right amount is.
Unknown Speaker• -
Right now, without the cash flow, it was a vote for 25 to bring to council.
Martha Garcia• -
But with council's direction, we could do another cash flow and determine what that right number would be.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
I think that would be helpful, yes, given great conditions of change, I'm sure, in the last two years.
Unknown Speaker• -
and then yeah I understand the the potential value in terms of investing
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
directly with and having our assets
Unknown Speaker• -
invested directly through Chandler or some sort of investment manager I'm just
Unknown Speaker• -
trying to get my head wrapped around like
Unknown Speaker• -
the potential if there if there are any potential risks and to think about this more
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
For one, I'm personally not ready to make a decision on this tonight. This is the first I'm hearing that we've had, that this has been an ongoing conversation with Chandler and not having the context around this, RFPing this two years ago. And I'd like to go back and look at the conversation from Council
Unknown Speaker• -
on what happened two years ago
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
and why we ended up not going forward on anything. Not to say that I have not predetermined anything, I just want to do more homework on this at least that's my personal view and then just to get this a little bit more And maybe in the meantime we can do a casual analysis to come back with staff Kind of analysis on that and what's available and knowing what we're projecting going forward in the next couple years Do you Martha you know offhand what our Minus the street water like revenue a special fund Better invested our current reserve policy for general fund. What's that?
Unknown Speaker• -
that amount?
Unknown Speaker• -
What's the set aside?
Unknown Speaker• -
Our policy follows the GFOA,
Martha Garcia• -
which is having enough for
Unknown Speaker• -
two months cash flow.
Unknown Speaker• -
So it would only be two months of our so it's about $6 million
Martha Garcia• -
that we would have to keep in reserves.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
So that we would keep in lay for lay-sip
Unknown Speaker• -
and everything else. Correct. But we do have a lot
Unknown Speaker• -
of projects right now
Martha Garcia• -
that are being used.
Unknown Speaker• -
There's ARPA money
Martha Garcia• -
within the portfolio. and we are purchasing our equipment for the playgrounds. So that's going to take about $2 million out of the portfolio that we haven't. I haven't seen all the expenditures come in.
Unknown Speaker• -
And then we have a lot of the streets is not coming.
Unknown Speaker• -
It's not in our, the street bond funds are not in our portfolio. They're kept with the fiscal agents.
Martha Garcia• -
So you're not really seeing, you don't see those in our portfolio.
Unknown Speaker• -
But we do have a lot of water and sewer infrastructure that's happening. If I might just ask, could you please back up and go to the investment strategies? Because I think it's really important given the interest rate environment that we're in today. Two years ago when we were here, interest rates were very near zero. And so now the city has an opportunity to really create investment income.
Unknown Speaker• -
Now, if you look at that one- to three-year investment strategy, you can see that 33% of the portfolio naturally matures between zero and one year. So if you needed funds from the $25 million that invest, that happens very naturally. Again, if you go out to the one to three year bucket,
Unknown Speaker• -
you can see that between zero and three years,
Unknown Speaker• -
over 80% of your assets mature between three years' time. So you have an opportunity to lock in yields currently at 5% and allow those funds, those monies to marinate and grow. And you can facilitate liquidity if you absolutely need to from those funds. We are not necessarily recommending that the city do more. What we'd like to do is start with a $25 million allocation, meet with staff quarterly, present to council annually, and if you have the opportunity to invest more, you can. But if you do not, that's okay. You have a $25 million reserve that will create investment income for the long term. And that's really how we operate with the vast majority of our clients, especially gateway cities who are smaller and have more outflow requirements.
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
So Mia, thank you for those comments. I appreciate those comments. My view on this is I probably want to just dive in and sit on this, review a little bit more factual background. My promise to you is if we go with you guys,
Unknown Speaker• -
which is probably a good likelihood,
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
it shouldn't be $25 million.
Unknown Speaker• -
It should be $26 million.
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
And you understand why, because you're smiling.
Unknown Speaker• -
Oh, thank you. Okay.
Unknown Speaker• -
Council Member Yu?
Unknown Speaker• -
Just for your information, I look into your website and then also the form that you guys feel on the ADV Part 1. You guys are using Charles Schwab as your broker dealer. just for your information, this is actually on the website, and this reason is the most current form that under the rep fee program. I understand that you may be using possibly multiple, but then on the form is actually said all the asset pretty much. I'm not going to argue with you, but just for information, you're not using 35, 30, you know, broker dealer. And also go back to Mayor Pro Tem questions about why we decided not to use them two years ago. is because of the interest rate. Actually, I'm the one who banned them and stopped the investment there. You can look back at the video. So two years ago, the interest rate was almost down to zero, and the bond rate is really high. So at the time, I don't think it's the right timing to get in. And now I bring them back just because I think now is the right timing. When the interest rate goes up, maybe we have one to two more times this year, but pretty much we may lock down and may come back down. So I think now is actually a lot better timing. I'm not saying the best. So that's how I decided to bring you guys back. And why is not other firm? Actually, for RIA, they are very, they have each different RIA. There's tons of RIA out there. But then each of them has the niche. So what they are actually specializing is the public fund, public asset. And what they do is mostly very similar, I would say, to a lot of the city. And then they manage it under the city requirement compliance. But a lot of RIAs out there, they're not specializing in public funds. As you know, public funds are not the fancy thing out there. It's only the very short-term bonds. And then the income that they're making is very thin, I would say. So not a lot of RIAs, they want to do that. even though their number looks big but then you can see their their income their fee is very low compared to outside so um i'm i'm i don't object if you wanted to look for other firm but um i think that's pretty much um similar out there and i i have a question that for you guys is um the allocations that you guys are giving us. Can you backtrack? Can you backtrack for the last two years? I wanted to see the same portfolio that you proposed today. And let's say for two years ago, if we buy into the same portfolio, I'm sure you have all the data in place already. So give us the amount, give us the price. Let's say, for example, if we bought into what I assume is 100% two years ago. And now what is the price right now? I expect it's Lor. Let's say, for example, 90, okay? And so 90, 80, I don't know what the price, because you're a short-term bond. So I don't think the fluctuation will be as much as our bond that we underwrite like 25 years. If it's a 25 years bond, that will be fluctuated dramatically, like maybe 20, 30 percent. But yours is only one to three or one to five. So it's very thin, I would say, maybe hopefully 90%. So if we buy into it now at 90%, so we're getting in at a discount, I would say, at a better pricing. So I want them to, for the financial team, their advisory team, to know what the fluctuation can be. Because two years ago, it would be very low interest rate, which is very high bond rate. And we want to know the pricing there compared to now. and maybe in the future they can make decisions into when they want to maybe reduce or add more to the portfolio so that they know what the fluctuations, the range will be.
Unknown Speaker• -
So in the disclosure portion of the portfolio, we do have our global investment performance standard performance. We are independently verified, and because of our strong culture of compliance, this is all required our general counsel provides it, And we can go ahead and forward, Kara, to slide 29.
Unknown Speaker• -
So this just jumps in a bit towards performance over the last one year, three year, five years,
Unknown Speaker• -
10 years, and 20 years for those specific strategies, inclusive of gross and net of fees
Unknown Speaker• -
compared to the benchmarks there.
Unknown Speaker• -
So this will show the performance of those specific strategies that we are proposing for the city.
So what you can see here is, while we work on that, for the Chandler limited gross for one year, it's in at 1.01%.
Unknown Speaker• -
The net is 0.91%.
Unknown Speaker• -
but versus the benchmark of ISP of A, 1-3, or U.S. Treasury Index, that had a total rate of return,
Unknown Speaker• -
and total rate of return, again, is inclusive of realized and unrealized gains and losses plus interest income.
Unknown Speaker• -
The index shows 0.13%.
Unknown Speaker• -
Is that better? Okay.
I didn't.
If, right, if first, if, right, something like GAP, right, happened, the good views abatement
Unknown Speaker• -
has to happen, we have to pull money out, right, that Lors our investment with Chandler
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
below $25 million, what happens?
Unknown Speaker• -
You'd have to be invoiced at the minimum annual fee. So it would be approximately, let's just say, 10 basis points, and I'm probably quoting a little bit higher than the actual fee. So you would have to meet that fee criteria for $25 million. So it's a minimum fee. And if you go, But you're not going to take your money out willy-nilly from day one to day two. These would be conversations that we'd have. We'd help facilitate that liquidity. We would make accommodations for the city. We would want to have conversations with Inez and Martha and finance staff. So it's not like, you know, we believe firmly that if we do what's right for our clients, our own success will follow. So we're here as a co-fiduciary sitting really on the same side of the desk as you. I think it's important, too, that slide 33 shows all of the annual performance. And maybe that can be shared with Councilwoman you and council for tomorrow.
Unknown Speaker• -
But those are GIPS returns annual, and they will have to be increased dramatically. And you can see that one-year number for 2022 going all the way back to 2012.
Unknown Speaker• -
And you do see those negative numbers. However, that is just with the unrealized gains and losses. So the amount that you just see on paper happened to outweigh the actual percentage of interest income. So these portfolios were still earning income, even though they were showing a negative performance. And I would just like to add on with Bia Corral, yes, we are investment managers. However, we are also risk managers and have a heavy focus into the compliance of the program and many parameters set with our compliance team being separate from our investment team, as well as having Bloomberg AIM set up so we do pre- and post-trade compliance checks on any trades that we do place.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you. So any other quick question for Martha? When we did RFP this two years ago, was it customer service and the level of service that...
Unknown Speaker• -
similar. So it wasn't cost related. It was mostly customer service, the level of the
Martha Garcia• -
reporting that the Chandler would be providing in comparison to the other companies. And
Unknown Speaker• -
they were, one of them was so poor that he was, it was just very badly presented to us.
Unknown Speaker• -
And then the other one was moderate, okay, but the customer service level, Chandler's going to be meeting with us quarterly.
Martha Garcia• -
That was not part of the other company, the other firm. Chandler had an online system where we can monitor and pull all our reports. That wasn't going to be something they were going to offer.
Unknown Speaker• -
So it was how much we were going to get for our money versus the other companies.
Unknown Speaker• -
Great. One last comment. I don't think that the minimum fee, the portfolio minimum is higher with some of the larger firms. So
Unknown Speaker• -
PFM, for example, public finance management will not take an account under $40 million.
Unknown Speaker• -
Okay. One more question. Council Member, you? One more question. Just to echo what the fee is. I think you guys, the fear is the Lost, I would say, among the industry. So that's how they can get a lot of clients from other cities.
Unknown Speaker• -
And the 0.1, which is 10 basis points, is only one-tenth of a percent. And usually for a lot of firms out there, I mean, I used to do the business. I mean, less than 1%, I won't even consider. So you are 0.1 of a 1%.
Unknown Speaker• -
And also for the $25 million, they only charge about $2,000 per month. I mean, this is a very, very good price, I would say, among the industry. So I would say I would be understanding why you get a lot of clients. But then the amount doesn't mean anything because it's the income, the fee that you charge. So I would say compared to others, hardly find anything that will be Lor than them. But I do see that they have a big team, and they are very professional. But, you know, feel free to shop around out there, and I will be happy to find anything better than them. I will be happy to entertain those. So any other questions? Council Member Ngo?
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
Clearly your customer service is showing because you're affecting change, and you're explaining yourself, and you're providing a lot of good resources and information.
I can go either way tonight, but what I'm really curious is you pitch. This is your first pitch to me.
Unknown Speaker• -
Yes.
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
And I'm a risk person background, so it's probably a little bit harder. At the same time, I want to give you the benefit of the doubt, and I think you made a pitch to a team, and I think you did a good job with the team.
Unknown Speaker• -
That's why they're presenting it.
Unknown Speaker• -
In that pitch, I'm almost curious because I didn't see it.
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
I'm almost curious to see, did you take baseline? Did you take standard deviations above it? Did you play around with the portfolio for the next six months, one year, two years? Did you go about that, or is it just very basic in terms of asset allocation?
Unknown Speaker• -
So what we do, you know, we have the benchmarks that we're showing here. Essentially, we have multiple committees that the investment team comprises,
Unknown Speaker• -
and one of those is the qualitative committee. So I sit on that committee, and what we do is we take information from our economic team as well as the credit analysis team and take that information that they're seeing as well as proposed
Unknown Speaker• -
interest rates that we're seeing in the future and put those into a few models that we have to give us an anticipated duration set for the next six months and from that we may extend duration we may shorten duration slightly just based upon that information so we do periodically if not at least monthly, we evaluate those quantitative tables to ensure that they're appropriate and do a six-month outlook for what we're seeing happening. And we'll take different interest rate scenarios that may occur, as well as different potential credit risks that we're seeing happening, and try to get a balance of where we're seeing, and then we come into an agreement, present that information to our investment team, and then we move forward with our investment strategies. So within that also, I mentioned a credit committee. What they do is they'll look at our corporate holdings that we have and do a deep dive analysis on those by issuer and industry to ensure that we are selecting not only securities that are rated A or higher, but entities that we believe will continue to be of that grade, if not better.
Unknown Speaker• -
Okay.
Unknown Speaker• -
Martha, another question. I know we currently purchase CDs.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
Do we have an investment manager that assists with that,
Unknown Speaker• -
or do we do that directly with some staff?
Unknown Speaker• -
We have a broker.
Martha Garcia• -
We use MBS, I think MBS, and we purchase CDs through them.
Unknown Speaker• -
But that's all they do? They only do CDs?
Unknown Speaker• -
They did do securities, but it takes the short-term ones.
Unknown Speaker• -
There's like three months, and those have a higher interest rate,
Martha Garcia• -
but it takes a three to one vote for me to approve that purchase and they go fast like within 30 minutes to an hour in the morning so we don't have enough time to take the vote to get to purchase
Unknown Speaker• -
those but they do offer other other types of purchases okay uh i mean i this is also the first
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
time i'm hearing this uh pitch as well i echo kind of some of uh councilman rego's comments uh i
Unknown Speaker• -
I WOULD LIKE TO SIT ON THIS A LITTLE BIT LONGER AND I'M NOT READY TO MAKE A DECISION PERSONALLY TONIGHT.
Unknown Speaker• -
I DON'T KNOW WHERE THE OTHER COUNCIL MEMBERS ARE.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
BUT IF I CAN SUGGEST CONTINUING THIS CONVERSATION FOR THE NEXT COUNCIL MEAN. I KNOW WE DON'T HAVE ANOTHER ONE FOR THIS MONTH, SO IT WOULD BE OCTOBER AT THE EARLIEST. BUT I WOULD LIKE TO SIT ON THIS A LITTLE BIT.
Unknown Speaker• -
COUNCIL MEMBER?
Council Member Henry Lo• -
I just question again just for their information so is there enough time for my colleagues you know especially if we defer to October to get the information that they've been asking for tonight?
Unknown Speaker• -
Would we have enough time?
What information are we asking for? Can you just clarify? I'm not sure.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
I'm not asking for anything specific. I just want to look through some more. Potentially we'll have some more questions for staff but
Unknown Speaker• -
I'm not ready to vote on this
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
just at this moment tonight.
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
I'm kind of curious but it's kind of irrelevant at this point because you came two years ago. Whatever was in that proposal, it's moot and it probably was not a positive return because of what we are with the rate today. You made a pitch, was it this month or last month or based on pro forma of what data time?
Unknown Speaker• -
I'd say we've had ongoing conversations with staff, checking in with them, let's say, every six months, if you will. I think that even if you decide not to engage us today, we hope that you'll consider adopting the policy. The analysis and the work that went into that was very thorough. I think it will help to elevate the city's investment program and give you a blueprint, if you will, for working with an external investment advisor in the future. If you want to consider working with Chandler Asset Management, you can feel free to follow up with me. I definitely want to make sure that I provide performance numbers in a larger format and take a look at that item in our ADV related to broker-dealers and ensure that it is accurate. And I'm going to provide a certificate of insurance so you have that information for background. I think ultimately all I can say is we are the investment experts for the public sector clients in our home state of California. Any other RIA that you interview will not be a California-based firm. They will not have the breadth and depth of experience that we have, nor the reputation.
Unknown Speaker• -
And I really encourage you to take a look at that list. If you want to reach out to any of those public agencies, I'll provide you with reference information and contact information. I think any client that has hired us has retained us, and we'll tell you that we have really been able to provide investment value
Unknown Speaker• -
to their program over long periods of time. So thank you very much for allowing us to take up so much oxygen tonight. Thank you.
Martha Garcia• -
I also want to add that our current portfolio does not have the diversity that it requires for our policy. The old one and if the new one is adopted today, We do need to invest in another party or with another entity because we have enough money. We have a significant large portfolio that requires more diversity. Amy, our city treasurer, and I have been working together. We are looking forward to possibly getting the CTMA certificate, which is the California Treasury Municipality Association. I think that's what the, and we would have to diversify as well so that we can be eligible for that certificate.
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
So I do have an ask, but it could be moot depending on how the vote goes tonight. I guess if there's, you have a majority here, then my ask would be moot. But my ask would be this. Based on my assumption that I'd like you guys to go back and come back next month and present it, the pitch that you did based on a 25 i'm going to round it up to 26 million because i am cost efficient okay let's do 26 million based on what you have today let's run the numbers and crank out let's see what the next six months a year would be because potentially there could be another 25 in november and that would be it that's the latest although that changes almost every week
Unknown Speaker• -
That's synopsis one.
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
Synopsis two, if you look at something that's around $26 million, $25 million, whatever, close enough, from another city that is around Southern California, and you can redact the names, but tell us how they performed over the last six months, or maybe because it's September now.
Unknown Speaker• -
Year-to-date, nine months. That's really the information you have.
Unknown Speaker• -
The composite information that we've provided is for existing clients. Okay, year-to-date. With names redacted. We don't cherry pick when we provide performance numbers. We adhere per compliance and the SEC to the global investment performance standards. So all of the performance that we show you exists. We do not have the ability to create like a forward-looking performance appraisal to share with you. That, quite frankly, is not legal. we can show you historical performance but we do not have the ability to um to create performance let's say six months out what we can say is our strategies are performing um in this manner the investments are locked in at these rates and you can expect to receive similar rates over the next six months um if if the fed is going to increase one or two times i would say a lot of those increases are already baked in but but we will continue to invest in at least this environment for the next six months based on on the conversations that are occurring in the markets
Unknown Speaker• -
currently so i guess what i'm hearing is that we just want to kind of sit on this and think about
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
it a little bit more and find maybe ways that we can bring them back and do another presentation i'm not sure if it might be necessary also to have like maybe a special council meeting or something to kind of go over some of these numbers and maybe ask the more.
Council Member Henry Lo• -
Mr. Mayor, the item will be continued then to the next council meeting?
Unknown Speaker• -
Right, there are two items here.
Unknown Speaker• -
I'm ready to make a motion on 3D to approve the new investment policy
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
and then 3E to continue. And I think in the meantime until the next meeting when this is on the agenda,
Unknown Speaker• -
maybe we could ask for a new cash flow analysis
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
and if there are any updates to these numbers since we did the RFP two years ago. I mean it looks like we've updated a lot of this analysis already in this pitch But if there's anything else in the meantime that would be helpful
Unknown Speaker• -
to update
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
We can do that too and then bring this back to council in October So with that I'll make a motion for us to approve 3d the new investment policy
Unknown Speaker• -
Let's do one at a time. So let's do so there's a motion for
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
for 3Ds are seconded by Council Member Yu if we can take a vote on 3D.
Unknown Speaker• -
Approved unanimously.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
And if I heard correctly, there is a motion to bring back 3E.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
Do we need a motion or is that just, we can just continue it.
Unknown Speaker• -
We'll continue the conversation.
Unknown Speaker• -
Actually, I would like to suggest maybe there's a special session for us to, you know,
Unknown Speaker• -
have for the investment portfolio because we're not all having the same background. So it will be good to have education sessions for all of us before the next or
Unknown Speaker• -
next time we bring it up so that we have a more understanding of how they pick the investment. Thank you. Thank you. And maybe we can set
Unknown Speaker• -
up a date sometime in October or late September. We can come
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
up with a date together. Thank you so much for answering and fielding our questions. Hopefully, you know, we can, we'll see how this goes, but we appreciate your time and we look forward to continuing to speak to you and work with you.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you.
Unknown Speaker• -
We'll go ahead and jump to item 3F.
Unknown Speaker• -
Who, was that you?
Unknown Speaker• -
Yeah, just a very, very abbreviated staff report.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you.
Unknown Speaker• -
Good evening, Mayor, Mayor Portem, and Council Members.
Unknown Speaker• -
My name is Stanley Arden. I'm the IT manager for the city. This evening, basically...
Unknown Speaker• -
causing a periodic internet loss and email connectivity citywide. In order to improve the network stability,
Unknown Speaker• -
I would like to propose to upgrade the infrastructure and improve cybersecurity.
Unknown Speaker• -
The city is requesting to amend the agreement with existing vendor
Unknown Speaker• -
with Network Magic by modifying the scope of service to include the purchase and installation of two firewalls, upgrading email servers to the most current version,
Unknown Speaker• -
and reinforcing network infrastructure.
Unknown Speaker• -
for the total compensation of the amount of $228,900.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thanks, Stanley. So let me know if I'm reading,
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
if I read the staff report and I understand this correctly.
Unknown Speaker• -
The original agreement with Network Magic is a three-year agreement that originally
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
the agreement is for $29,000 and we're adding almost nine times that.
Unknown Speaker• -
That's correct, yes, sir.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
Can you detail a little bit more what we would be adding to the scope of the contract?
Unknown Speaker• -
Yeah, the original scope was basically to do an upgrade just for one of our fire stations.
Unknown Speaker• -
And all of this that we're basically looking at is upgrading our firewalls,
Unknown Speaker• -
upgrading a lot of our network design, and restructuring a lot of our network and putting us in a better cybersecurity position is what I'm proposing to add.
Unknown Speaker• -
A lot of this was already on cue online that we were planning on doing down the line, but based on some of the recent changes, it was just easier to come to council and just put everything in one lump sum instead of coming over for every project
Unknown Speaker• -
instead of coming in every single time we were going to make a project. And that's the reason why it kind of just lumps them into one big jump in price.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
All right, is there any reason we wouldn't RFP separately for these other services or is there some sort of efficiency with Network Magic?
Unknown Speaker• -
I'm proposing to sole source it and just put it all together
Unknown Speaker• -
Into one and just just because all the projects kind of overlap each other
Unknown Speaker• -
So it's easier just have one vendor just put everything together versus
Unknown Speaker• -
Breaking it up and having pieces because then every time we would have a different vendor come in
Unknown Speaker• -
they would have to redo evaluations and trying to put everything together.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
So there would be efficiency gains from doing this?
Unknown Speaker• -
Correct, yes.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
And so, I mean, my understanding, right, is that, so this would be essentially cybersecurity upgrades
Unknown Speaker• -
and network, right, improve network performance at all of our city facilities,
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
not just the fire station, right, to expand beyond just the fire station?
Unknown Speaker• -
That is correct, yes. That is for the whole city, yes.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
Are we planning or are we looking at other or do we need other upgrades to our IT infrastructure beyond this as well?
Martha Garcia• -
We always need to upgrade and keep renewing.
Unknown Speaker• -
We're working on a schedule so that our firewalls and all of our other cyber secure infrastructures
Martha Garcia• -
continuously update it so that nothing gets outdated. There's always going to be a need for additional infrastructure.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
Is Network Magic the only vendor we currently have working on our IT kind of infrastructure,
Unknown Speaker• -
or do we have others?
Unknown Speaker• -
NINTH.
Martha Garcia• -
We hired NINTH, and they provided and installed our servers. And then we have the NINTH contract who actually maintains our servers.
Unknown Speaker• -
All right.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
But it made more sense to go with network magic for these specific.
Unknown Speaker• -
For these particular items, yes.
Unknown Speaker• -
Okay. Yeah, I just appreciate staff working on this and being proactive
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
and understanding the growing threats in terms of cybersecurity and IT infrastructure threats to not just municipal governance, but all around, also for personal people in our communities,
Unknown Speaker• -
households that are under threat.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
And I think we mentioned scams earlier as well, proliferating in cybersecurity space as well. So appreciate the work we're doing here, and please keep the city council kind of apprised of these kind of upgrades, knowing that the need to invest in our IT infrastructure and security are probably going to increase significantly in the coming years, and particularly with other emerging threats continuing to proliferate too.
Unknown Speaker• -
That's great. Thank you, sir.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
That's all I had. I fully support this agreement. I just piqued my interest that we were adding this much amount to a low base amount for the contract, but I understand why.
Unknown Speaker• -
Yes, sir. Thank you.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
With that, I'll make the motion to approve staff's recommendation.
Unknown Speaker• -
Is there a second?
Unknown Speaker• -
I second it.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you. I'm seconded by Council Member Lo if we can take a vote.
Unknown Speaker• -
Approved unanimously.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you. And I think we'll jump to item 3N, Environmental Systems Research Institute.
Unknown Speaker• -
A very quick report, if possible.
Shawn Igoe• -
Good evening, Honorable Mayor, Mayor Pro Temp, City Council. Sean Igoe, Public Works Director. Tonight we have before you an item for Environmental Systems Research Institute, or ESRI. It's an enterprise license for our GIS system. If you recall, a few meetings back, I did a presentation with our GIS system demonstrating our CIP program and how it interacts with the public and they can pull up projects. This is an enterprise agreement that allows not only ourselves within Public Works but other users such as FHIR, PD, Community Development that are currently using this system to all merge together under a larger enterprise license.
Unknown Speaker• -
So with that, I'll take any questions.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thanks, I just wanted to applaud the Public Works Department,
Unknown Speaker• -
Sean, and everyone for moving more to use GIS
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
and integrate that into our operations and also making these tools and the ability for residents to be able to see what we're doing more easily and hope that we will adopt more of the GIS and other mapping tools for us to be able to present data to residents and community members more easily and more visually to going forward on all the data kind of points and interactions that
Unknown Speaker• -
we have with with the community while we are here i know we already passed the the next side of the
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
ct and t the best pad repairs along garvey and atlantic and all that just wondering if you can get a very quick update on the schedule for that and when we are Garvey Avenue traffic nightmares
Shawn Igoe• -
might be easing we're anticipating to be completed with Garvey by the end of this week so we're hoping that we'll be back to normal after this week after the bus pads are complete that's for
Unknown Speaker• -
just the bus pads the rest of the construction will continue after that cool my parents who I
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
saw over the holiday weekend will be very relieved to hear that the traffic will be easing on Garvey SO ALL WILL BE RELIEVED THEY WILL WE'LL ALL BE VERY VERY HAPPY UH APPRECIATE THAT UM I DON'T THINK I HAD ANY OTHER QUESTIONS ON THIS BUT I CAN'T FIND THEM SO I'M HAPPY TO MAKE A MOTION TO APPROVE THIS
Unknown Speaker• -
UH ITEM 3 AND STAFF'S REGUMENDATION IS THERE A SECOND I'LL SECOND SECOND BY COUNCIL MEMBER GOEF WE CAN
Unknown Speaker• -
TAKE A VOTE PLEASE APPROVED UNANIMOUSLY THANK YOU THANKS AND JUST URGE ALL THE OTHER CITY DEPARTMENTS
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
who are using ESRI and GIS tools to continue to look for other opportunities to utilize the tool and to make some of this data more accessible for our community as well.
Unknown Speaker• -
Okay.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
We'll go ahead and jump to item 4A, public hearing, to review and approve the fiscal year 2022-23 consolidated annual performance and evaluation report. I'll go ahead and open public hearing on this item.
Unknown Speaker• -
Are there any...
Unknown Speaker• -
There's no comments?
Unknown Speaker• -
No speakers.
Unknown Speaker• -
Good evening, Mayor, Mayor Paton, Council Members, Martha Garcia, Finance Director.
Unknown Speaker• -
The city submits a consolidated annual performance and evaluation report to HUD
Martha Garcia• -
annually as one of the conditions of receiving federal funds
Unknown Speaker• -
under the CDBG and Home Programs.
Unknown Speaker• -
The CAPER outlines progress made in achieving these goals
Unknown Speaker• -
in the city's five-year consolidated plan.
Martha Garcia• -
And here to talk about it is our CDBG and Home Program
Unknown Speaker• -
consultant Priscilla Davila. She's on Zoom.
Unknown Speaker• -
Hi, good evening, everyone. Good evening, Mayor, members of the city council. In front of you tonight is a staff report that is dealing with HUD's 2022-2023 CAPER.
Unknown Speaker• -
consolidated annual performance and evaluation report. It needs to be submitted to HUD annually. The report and staff is recommending, one, opening the public hearing to receive testimony and document evidence, which we just did, two, approving the draft fiscal year 2022-2023 caper for the CDBG and home funds, three, directing staff to prepare and transmit the final documents to HUD, four, or authorizing the city manager or his designee to take all actions necessary or desirable to complete and submit the caper, and lastly, take any such actions, related actions that may be desirable. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development provides funding to states, counties, and cities in the form of Community Development Block Grant, we call it CDBG, and Home Investment Partnership Funds, home funds. Since the City of Monterey Park is an entitlement city, the city is eligible to receive both CDBG and home funds, which it has for many years. As a condition of receiving these funds, HUD requires the city to complete a CAPER to demonstrate what it accomplished during the program year related to CDBG and home funds. The City of Monterey Parks Housing Division has completed the CAPER, which covers the period of July 1st, 2022 through June 30th, 2023. The CAPER describes the overall use of federal community development block grant and home funds. A copy of the draft CAPER was attached to the staff report, and it was made available for public review starting August 21st, 2023 through September 5th, 2023. All comments will be incorporated into the final paper that is submitted to HUD. If you look at the report in front of you, you will see that it details how much funds were expended throughout the program year and exactly the accomplishments that were achieved throughout the program year. I'm available to answer any questions that you may have.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
Thank you. Are there any questions or comments from Council?
Unknown Speaker• -
Mayor Patum Wong?
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
I appreciate the report being put together, and I understand this is a look back at what we achieved over the last year, and I think when we had a similar report come up a few months ago, I brought up my interest, at least, personally, and understanding this next year is already programmed. We had to submit that report to HUD for use of these funds, But for the next cycle that's available to make sure that we're coming back to council with other options for how to spend these funds I can think of a hundred other things for us to consider Potentially to provide support for the community where I know that there are always more needs than there are resources available including in this case with our home and CDBG funds, but just looking at some of the THE ACCOMPLISHMENTS THAT WE'RE LISTING HERE IN THE CAPER AND IN THE LAST REPORT OUT, THAT I THINK THERE ARE OTHER THINGS WE SHOULD CONSIDER IN TERMS OF PROVIDING SUPPORT TO COMMUNITY MEMBERS AND OTHERS IN TERMS OF ADDRESSING HOUSING NEEDS AND LOW-INCOME PARTS OF THE COMMUNITY, THEIR NEEDS FOR ASSISTANCE, RIGHT, JUST OFF THE TOP OF MY HEAD, AS I'VE NOTED ON MY OWN KIND OF WHEN I WENT THROUGH THIS AGENDA PACKET, RIGHT, UTILITY RATE ASSISTANCE, I KNOW WE'RE already used this for our net team for overnight shelter and providing housing for some homeless individuals that our net team encounters and those that are open to services, but also providing tenant and landlord education around requirements for new and emerging requirements for landlords and tenants' rights education efforts. I know we do a little bit of that in a limited way with some workshops, but bolstering some of those efforts looking at other home buyer assistance or education efforts looking at funding those and funding potentially other nonprofits that provide those services already in our city or in our region other efforts to prevent homelessness partner with the schools provide grants other programs that exist to provide right these kind of services and resources education to families through those avenues as well. Senior and there's a good amount of senior affordable housing that exists in the community. A lot of those facilities are aging and coming to a point where they need major maintenance. Potentially a grant program or a low or zero interest loan program for those facilities and existing affordable housing projects that are here in the city to provide financial assistance for them to do necessary and needed improvements or maintenance projects as well. Potentially economic development opportunities that we could fund through this additionally. So a whole host of other things that I think we should start to consider going into the next time that this opportunity comes up to program these funds. I just want to make sure that we're bringing that back to council. But don't have any issues with this report.
Unknown Speaker• -
It's a look back. Nothing to change here. Appreciate staff's efforts.
Unknown Speaker• -
on all of these efforts and achievements. I know that a lot goes into this
Unknown Speaker• -
and a lot of resources are required as well
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
to provide these programs and services. And I know that a lot will continue to be required
Unknown Speaker• -
to expand this going forward.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
So I appreciate the work that went.
Unknown Speaker• -
Is there a second?
Unknown Speaker• -
I'll second. I have a second.
Unknown Speaker• -
All right.
Unknown Speaker• -
Is there, can we please vote?
Unknown Speaker• -
Approved unanimously.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
So we'll go ahead and close hearing on item 4A and open hearing on item 4B, a continued public hearing to consider adopting a resolution establishing citywide related
Unknown Speaker• -
sorry
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
citywide fees related to the inclusionary housing
Unknown Speaker• -
ordinance.
Are there any speakers on item 4B?
Thank you. And when you're ready Mayor Sanchez, members of the City Council, this is Jessica Serrano your community development director
Unknown Speaker• -
and I'm here to present a continued public hearing item to consider inclusionary housing fees.
Unknown Speaker• -
As an overview, the inclusionary housing ordinance was approved by City Council for first reading on August 16th.
Unknown Speaker• -
Tonight, the City Council approved second reading of the ordinance, and the ordinance goes into effect on October 6th, 30 days after today.
Unknown Speaker• -
As part of the inclusionary housing ordinance,
Unknown Speaker• -
one of the options to comply with the regulations is to pay an in-loo fee.
Unknown Speaker• -
The resolution under consideration will establish a formula from which in-loo fees are calculated. The formula is based on the affordability gap, which represents the difference between the market rate and the affordable price of an affordable unit. The in-loo fee will be calculated on a project-by-project basis, and a consultant is needed to calculate the fee. Developers will be required to pay for the consultant cost plus 25.4% of the consultant cost plus the in-lieu fee. And additionally, City Council had previously directed staff to look into having a financial evaluation conducted on our inclusionary housing ordinance. Staff has been in communication with the San Gabriel Valley Regional. I'm sorry San Gabriel Valley Council of Governments to determine whether they can assist us with this, so we're still working with them We'll keep you posted on the outcome of that at this point and I wanted to mention also the results of the financial evaluation could potentially Change the the calculation that's being approved or considered tonight You know based on the the results of the financial evaluation study At this point I'm going to turn over the rest of the presentation to Beth Chow our interim planning manager
Unknown Speaker• -
Good evening mayor members of the council the next part of this presentation will detail what an example project May look like in terms of in lieu fees based on the affordability gap formula So each of the examples we'll be looking at will be based on a project that has 10 units and how the inclusionary housing fee will be applied to that.
Unknown Speaker• -
In this slide, the calculation looks at a for sale project where total in lieu fee will be $300,000 based on the difference of the market rate unit versus the affordable rate unit where there's a gap of $200,000 per unit. then typically we would apply the factor of 1.5 as required by our inclusionary housing ordinance that was approved this evening. Then the total would be that $300,000 gap that developers would then have to pay to the city. So in calculating a project that's for rent, the affordability gap is generally calculated a little differently. while the gap is still the difference between the market rate unit and the affordable rate unit, the data used to calculate the values includes other dynamics such as ongoing costs of operations of a rental project, including things like taxes or insurance. And so here in the same 10-unit scenario, but for rental units, the market rates and affordable units only have a gap of $150,000 per unit. Applying the same factor to this gap, the resulting in lieu fee is $225,000 for that same project under a rental scenario. Next, please.
Unknown Speaker• -
As in lieu fees are calculated and collected, they'll be put into an affordable housing trust fund that is created as part of the proposed resolution this evening.
Unknown Speaker• -
The list below is a sampling of what in lieu fees may be used for.
Unknown Speaker• -
However, at a later time, once the fund has an adequate fund balance, council will need to set the priority of what those in lieu fees may be used for
Unknown Speaker• -
in relation to affordable housing within our city.
Unknown Speaker• -
At this point, staff is recommending that council have the public hearing
Unknown Speaker• -
and then after the public hearing adopt the attached resolution as proposed and taking any additional or related action that may be desirable. This concludes
Unknown Speaker• -
staff's presentation and we are available for any questions. Thank you for that
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
report and are there any questions or comments from Council? Council Member Lo?
Council Member Henry Lo• -
Thank you Mr. Mayor. Again, thank you for that presentation. Just one question at the moment.
Unknown Speaker• -
So the proposed in-loop fees, how does that compare to surrounding cities that have similar in-loop fees?
Unknown Speaker• -
So as we surveyed other surrounding cities, many of their formulas on how to calculate fees were also based on the affordability gap specifically, I believe Alhambra and Pastina.
Unknown Speaker• -
However, those two cities had those individual fee analysis by consultants who are experts in market and affordable housing rates that were able to provide the data for those in lieu fees.
Unknown Speaker• -
Other questions? Mayor Portemont.
Unknown Speaker• -
On that note, I don't know if I heard you right,
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
but the staff report indicates that we are moving forward with the COG doing that analysis for helping to set the rate for affordable units and all that stuff, and then this in Luffy will be part of that calculation analysis too.
Unknown Speaker• -
At this point, we're still in communication with the COG as to whether they're going to be able to help us with that study.
Unknown Speaker• -
but in theory the feasibility study would be looking at our market conditions any impacts of
Unknown Speaker• -
the inclusionary housing ordinance that was adopted and they'll also do an in in lieu fee
Unknown Speaker• -
analysis as well okay so it were i mean when i read the staff report it says sgv cog offered
Unknown Speaker• -
to assist cities efforts employing iho having financial validation by their consultants by FIRST QUARTER OF 2024 SO THAT'S NOT SET YET IT'S NOT SET WE'RE STILL IN COMMUNICATIONS WITH THEM ON THAT
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
UH IN PARALLEL CAN WE CONSIDER IF IF THE COG CAN'T UH GO FORWARD WITH THAT CAN WE FIGURE OUT HOW
Unknown Speaker• -
WE CAN DO THAT ON OUR OWN I THINK IT WOULD BE IMPORTANT TO ME I DON'T KNOW ABOUT THE OTHER I
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
HOPE THE OTHER COUNCILERS AS WELL TO HAVE THIS ANALYSIS DONE AS QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE TO MAKE SURE THAT OUR ORDINANCE AND THE FEE MATCH MARKET CONDITIONS TO THE EXTENT POSSIBLE AS SOON AS POSSIBLE SO THAT whatever is in our development pipeline might potentially come into our development pipeline
Unknown Speaker• -
in the coming months.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
It's something that we don't want to discourage those projects that may or may not be viable
Unknown Speaker• -
to have this kind of, right, we want to make sure we're setting this as quickly as possible.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
Ideally, right, we would have had this analysis done
Unknown Speaker• -
to set the IHO and the fee to begin with,
Unknown Speaker• -
and I know we're kind of doing this after the fact,
Unknown Speaker• -
but whatever we can do to accelerate this process
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
TO GET THE ANALYSIS DONE AND TO GET THESE NUMBERS RIGHT TO THE EXTENT POSSIBLE. I KNOW IT'S ALWAYS A MOVING TARGET SOMETIMES. BUT WE'D LOVE TO SEE THIS ANALYSIS DONE SOONER RATHER THAN LATER. AND IF WE NEED TO EXPEND FUNDS TO DO THAT, IF THE COG IS TAKING YOU LONG OR OUR TIMELINE WITH THEM EXCEEDS THIS, THEN MAYBE WE CAN ACCELERATE THIS WITH OUR OWN FUNDS SOMEHOW.
Unknown Speaker• -
NOTED. WE'LL MOVE EXPEDITIOUSLY.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you any other questions or comments from council no okay thank you
Unknown Speaker• -
Do we need a motion for the oh yeah do we need them yeah all right so I want to make a motion
Unknown Speaker• -
here I'll make the motion up since the motion is to continue the poking so we need a second
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
READING OF THIS? OR WHAT DOES THAT MEAN?
Karl Berger• -
THE MR. MAYOR, MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL, THIS IS A RESOLUTION ADOPTING THE FEE.
Unknown Speaker• -
THE SECOND READING WAS ON CLOSED OR ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
FOR THE IHL. AND THIS IS JUST WE DON'T.
Karl Berger• -
THIS JUST SETS THE ACTUAL FEE AND SO IT'S A RESOLUTION AND IT BECOMES EFFECTIVE AT THE
Unknown Speaker• -
SAME TIME THAT THE ORDINANCE BECOMES EFFECTIVE.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
All right, so I'll make the motion, staff's recommendation to adopt the resolution with the citywide fees. With the understanding that we're going to come back, staff will come back once we complete this analysis, if we make any necessary changes, both the ICO and the fee resolution.
Unknown Speaker• -
All right. Thank you. I'll second that.
Unknown Speaker• -
Seconded by Council Member Lo, if we can please take a vote.
Approved unanimously. Thank you. So we'll go ahead and jump to new business items.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
Item 5A, which is a discussion of establishing a memorial committee for the January 21st mass shooting incident.
Unknown Speaker• -
Is there a brief report?
Unknown Speaker• -
Yes.
Unknown Speaker• -
Good evening, Mr. Mayor and City Council. Diana Garcia, Interim Assistant Manager, City Manager.
Unknown Speaker• -
The item before you this evening is a discussion of establishing a committee that would be
Diana Garcia• -
tasked with making decisions on a permanent memorial for the January 21st mass shooting
Unknown Speaker• -
in Monterey Park.
Diana Garcia• -
In response to the tragedy, we understand that there's been interest in the creation
Unknown Speaker• -
of a permanent memorial to serve as a place to remember the lives that were lost and as a symbol of resilience and unity for the community.
Unknown Speaker• -
I do want to note that city staff is planning a remembrance event on the anniversary of the event on the evening of Sunday, January 21st, 2024. And additional details will follow, but you can save the date for that.
Unknown Speaker• -
So communities that have been affected by similar tragedies have often established committees to tackle all of the issues surrounding the establishment of a permanent memorial.
Unknown Speaker• -
things like fundraising, outreach, planning. And those committees often consist of a diverse
Diana Garcia• -
group of individuals, so community members, stakeholders, survivors, family members, victims,
Unknown Speaker• -
and sometimes even experts in memorial design or public spaces.
Diana Garcia• -
This can be either an ad hoc city commission or a fully independent group. Many communities adopt independent commissions that are able to fundraise. Initial research on memorial committees and processes for six mass casualty events in the U.S. is attached to the staff report and that's provided tonight to help guide
Unknown Speaker• -
decision discussion rather.
Unknown Speaker• -
We know that there are many, many topics that a memorial committee itself would have to
Unknown Speaker• -
tackle.
Diana Garcia• -
Committee roles and responsibilities, location selection, concept and design, community engagement,
Unknown Speaker• -
BUDGETING, FUNDRAISING, PARTNERSHIPS, CONSTRUCTIONS, TIMELINE, AND COMMUNITY UPDATES.
Diana Garcia• -
SO WE'RE NOT NECESSARILY TRYING TO ANSWER ALL OF THOSE QUESTIONS THIS EVENING, BUT WE DO BRING THEM UP TO GIVE A BETTER UNDERSTANDING OF THE SCOPE OF A POSSIBLE COMMITTEE'S RESPONSIBILITIES. SO TONIGHT WE'D LIKE TO START THE CONVERSATION WITH COUNCIL AND COUNCIL MAY CHOOSE TO PROVIDE DIRECTION ON NEXT STEPS AND OR REQUEST THAT THIS ITEM IS PUT ON A FUTURE AGENDA FOR DISCUSSION at meetings in the future.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you. We're happy to answer any questions where we can, either to do additional research or to take any additional direction
Diana Garcia• -
that the Council would like to provide.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you, Diana, for that report.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
Are there any questions or comments from Council regarding the memorial for the January 21st victim?
Unknown Speaker• -
Yes, Mr. Mayor?
Unknown Speaker• -
Yes, I'm sorry.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
Council Member Henry Lo• -
And again, thank you, Diane, staff, for preparing this report. I, you know, what I find interesting just reading the examples that, you know, for example,
Unknown Speaker• -
you know, for the Orlando nightclub shooting, a committee was formed in 2017, and it looks
Unknown Speaker• -
like it, you know, it's incomplete yet because they're still waiting to collect money, but
Unknown Speaker• -
also just I think probably establishing conceptually what they want to see and I see in other examples
Council Member Henry Lo• -
it has taken a couple of years and so I would imagine if we were to form a committee probably one of the first things is to establish what are the parameters of what we want in a monument or memorial or is that something that the city council needs to set direction because
Unknown Speaker• -
I imagine if we do create a committee however it's composed, are we then to set at least
Unknown Speaker• -
some of the goals and objectives so that they are not just setting recommendations without
Unknown Speaker• -
parameters?
Unknown Speaker• -
Yes, I do believe that it would be a good idea for council to provide initial direction
Unknown Speaker• -
TO THE COMMITTEE. IN ADDITION TO NAMING SOME MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE OR ESTABLISHING A PROCESS TO DECIDE WHO WOULD SERVE ON THE COMMITTEE, I THINK SOME OF THE THINGS THAT COUNCIL WOULD CONSIDER.
Unknown Speaker• -
mentioned there are a lot of things that the committee would really have to sink their teeth into
Diana Garcia• -
and decide on their own but council should definitely provide some some initial guidance
Unknown Speaker• -
if i may um mayor and members of the council i think just another consideration point is even the commitment level of committee members um understanding that that these processes um in some cases have taken at minimum months and in some cases years.
Unknown Speaker• -
So committee members, I think, up front will need to have an understanding of what we're asking them to do, definitely. But what we're asking Council to start the discussion about is exactly that,
Unknown Speaker• -
is how is the committee going to be established?
Unknown Speaker• -
Is it going to be a selection process? Are committee members going to be appointed? and then just to be thoughtful about who's asked to participate on this committee, considering we put some examples here, but we understand that our event was not just unique to the city of Monterey Park or even our residents. It was more regional, and so to be mindful of who else is going to be included in that committee process. So just things to consider. as Diana mentioned, we don't have to have clear, definitive, finalized
Inez Alvarez• -
answers tonight, but we're just looking to start the conversation
Unknown Speaker• -
and if council need more time to digest the information and think about it, that's fine too. We could always continue the item. We just wanted
Unknown Speaker• -
to start with providing some background on how
Unknown Speaker• -
other communities have handled these types of incidents.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you. Council Member Ngo?
Unknown Speaker• -
So my initial thought here is this, as Council Member Lo mentioned, this can take a long time.
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
When you look at some of these projects, MCI events took upwards of 10 years to a decade. Hopefully ours won't take that long, but you have to have the mindset to know that it may take that long. I know tonight's a good start, but we do need a structure, and we do need to leverage the commissions in our city and staff to figure out who we want on that commission, because as the assistant city manager mentioned, I mean, this event took place in our city, but the components and the victims and the stakeholders involved,
Unknown Speaker• -
most of them, majority of them don't live in the city.
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
They just happen to happen in the place in the city. So there's going to be a lot of brainstorming, and my initial thought here is we go with one of our commission teams, and from there kind of start a brainstorming session and include stakeholders within our healing fund folks, members in that committee who are interested, expand that to local community members, because I know there are a lot of people who have wanted to raise their hand and want to be part of this because this is eventually a memorial that will be symbolic of what happened. And then we'll probably have to think about stakeholders,
groups outside the city who are somewhat involved in helping the aid to the victims, in helping with fundraising, in helping with additional support, whether mental, behavioral, or continued support in the future. So I don't think we will have an answer tonight, but I think tonight's a good start, and those are just some of my brainstorming coming through. And I'd like a little bit more time, personally for myself, to kind of read out some of those thoughts and give you more concrete names, and then we continue on from there.
Unknown Speaker• -
So those are my thoughts.
Unknown Speaker• -
Any other questions or comments?
Unknown Speaker• -
Mayor Proxem Wong.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
I might kind of along those lines, I think it would be helpful to have or to convene a roundtable or some sort of more informal kind of brainstorming session with community stakeholders just to get some ideas around what this might look like. I appreciate staff's work on putting some of this outline together on other processes that happened. Although I think we can probably dive a little bit deeper into some of these processes in terms of how they organize their own committees and how they kind of organize thoughts and ideas for how the memorial should be shaped physically and all that stuff and how to include public and community input on their process and both on their process and on physically how the memorial took shape and is taking shape. maybe we can task staff to do a deeper dive on some of these
Unknown Speaker• -
and another one I know it's not a recent gun violence incident
Unknown Speaker• -
but another memorial that's starting to take shape
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
in the city of Los Angeles for the 1871 the lynching of Chinese residents in the city of Los Angeles back in over 150 years ago now
Unknown Speaker• -
but there they went through a process to
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
that started with a large steering committee and then had a bunch of ideas they had initial funding seed funding from the city to provide funding for architects and designers to provide potential designs and then they settled on the steering committee kind of settled on potential sites for a memorial or memorials if it was a multi-site kind of thing and then and invited potential designs to come in,
Unknown Speaker• -
and they had a whole competition for that. So there's a long process.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
Maybe we can look into that as well to see what lessons we can learn from that recent process because I think that kind of played out just over the last two years.
Unknown Speaker• -
And then if we can do a deeper dive
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
on the memorials that are taking shape for these other shootings across the country to see more specifically how they set up any committees
Unknown Speaker• -
and their decision-making process
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
and their outreach and engagement process for getting input from the community around ideas
Unknown Speaker• -
for shaping their memorials. And then I think it would be helpful, right,
Unknown Speaker• -
to start with a convening internally
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
to parse through some of these ideas and thoughts, and then from there determine if it makes sense, how it makes sense to move forward from there. If it's appointing an outside committee or potentially handing this off to the healing committee if it's something they want to take on or someone else, or this is something we keep completely in house
Unknown Speaker• -
I THINK WE CAN KIND OF GO FROM THERE.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
I APPRECIATE THAT WE'RE STARTING TO THINK ABOUT THIS. I KNOW THERE HAVE BEEN FOLKS IN THE COMMUNITY THAT HAVE BEEN ACTIVE AND WANTING TO GET GOING AND WANTING TO CONTRIBUTE TO A PROCESS LIKE THIS. AND I THINK IT WILL BE HELPFUL TO BE ABLE TO LET THEM KNOW THAT WE'RE STARTING THE THINKING PROCESS AROUND THIS.
Unknown Speaker• -
THANK YOU. I JUST WANT TO ECHO A LOT OF THE THINGS. COUNCIL MEMBER, YOU? GO AHEAD.
Unknown Speaker• -
I have a question that may be for Kyle
Unknown Speaker• -
and if we use the commission to raise funds
Unknown Speaker• -
that would be similar to our healing fund right? For the city of Monterey Park sponsoring
Unknown Speaker• -
a fundraise for Monterey Park so how does that work?
Thank you Mr. Mayor and members of the council
Unknown Speaker• -
the community healing fund was created as you know for a specific purpose which was to accept
Karl Berger• -
donations on and distribute them to the victims and what you're talking about tonight is related but different and not to speak for the members of the oversight board that participate in the
Unknown Speaker• -
community healing fund but that you know as a matter of good government my recommendation would
Karl Berger• -
be to reach out to them and ask if this is something in addition that they'd be willing to participate in, and my suggestion would be to have a different formation for a memorial
Unknown Speaker• -
fund to keep it distinct from the donation fund, not just for practical good government
Karl Berger• -
reasons, but there may be also tax implications involved with it and what have you.
Unknown Speaker• -
I'm not the person that advises with regard to personal finances,
Karl Berger• -
but that was the whole reason that the healing fund was created in the first place, was to give people an opportunity who were donating money to actually have a tax deduction and to make sure that the persons that accepted funds from those donations would not have tax implications with it.
Unknown Speaker• -
The memorial fund is somewhat different.
Karl Berger• -
It certainly would have tax implications for those people that were donating toward it, whether they be corporations or individuals or what have you, but it's a different purpose altogether than what the Community Healing Fund was set up for. There's no reason in concept that that existing structure
Unknown Speaker• -
couldn't be altered or expanded,
Karl Berger• -
but it's simply not happening now, and my suggestion would be to keep the two functions separate. So those are my off-the-cuff types of thoughts about it on the moment. But I do believe that or encourage you to think about just creating an ad hoc committee to talk about those things, to come up with some solutions rather than having to reinvent the wheel here at the dais and come up with solutions that may or may not fit. As the interim city manager noted, not all these folks were from the Monterey Park community itself originally. I mean, they're part of the fabric now of the community, obviously.
Unknown Speaker• -
but they resided in neighboring communities
Karl Berger• -
and their families and loved ones may have different ideas about what the memorial should be or if there should be a memorial
Unknown Speaker• -
or whether it should be on public property or whatever the case may be.
Karl Berger• -
A lot of the case studies that I think were presented in the staff report
discussed, many of those occurred on public property. This didn't occur on public property. The tragedy occurred, obviously, on private property,
Unknown Speaker• -
and so that's one of the considerations that whomever's on this committee
Karl Berger• -
to form ideas and provide solutions and give suggestions should consider. These are not legal thoughts. These are just practical thoughts, having been in government for a long time,
Unknown Speaker• -
but things that you should consider.
Unknown Speaker• -
Yeah, I think.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you. And then I think that just to follow up is, yeah, I agree with you that have the ad hoc committee to decide it.
Unknown Speaker• -
Okay, what's the next step? But because they need to raise enough money to be able to do a certain level of memorial.
Unknown Speaker• -
So the money is also some of the drive that or decision making to see what the next step would be.
Unknown Speaker• -
So, yeah, it would be good to have the ad hoc committee to set up to make that decision. Thank you.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
I THINK TO ADDRESS I THINK SOME OF THE COUNCILMORE'S CONCERNS, I THINK IT'S RIGHT THERE ARE A NUMBER OF STEPS BEFORE WE EVEN GET TO FUNDRAISING AND THE FINANCIAL ASPECTS OF THE MEMORIAL, RIGHT?
Unknown Speaker• -
I THINK TO THE CITY ATTORNEY'S POINT, I WOULD ECHO, WE DON'T EVEN, WE NEED TO, IN MY MIND, THE FIRST
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
STEP IS REALLY TO JUST GATHER ALL THE QUESTIONS WE NEED TO ASK FIRST. WE DON'T EVEN HAVE THOSE, RIGHT? THERE ARE ALL THESE QUESTIONS ABOUT WHAT'S THE BEST WAY TO GO ABOUT THIS? What are right potential structures for going about this? How do we outreach to the victims and their families to make sure their inputs given here and right? What are all these like parameters that we should just be starting to think about? I think just being able to have a session that you know Adhoc committee or whatever to be able to gather all those to put all the questions out there on a list so that we can start
Unknown Speaker• -
figuring out how to answer
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
Gather answers to some of those questions before we can even get a point of like those memorial make sense right even a very basic question do we want to have one what kind of world do we have want to have what are some potential locations we're gonna look at one like all those things are right these pre questions that we need to put out there and parse through a little bit before we get to answering some of those and then that will kind of I think lead to other questions and the financial aspects and actually how to get there physically from there and I think to
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
I think the easy segue would be potentially to go just directly to the Healing Fund Committee already formed just as a good starting point since you guys already have a lot of the names
Unknown Speaker• -
and resources, right?
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
So, but Council Member Lo, you had a question?
Unknown Speaker• -
Yes, I do.
Unknown Speaker• -
Well, I guess we're asking, I imagine whatever committee is created, I'm sure probably one
Council Member Henry Lo• -
One question about standouts, probably what's happening to space where the dance hall, what
Unknown Speaker• -
shooting had occurred.
Council Member Henry Lo• -
Because as Karol mentioned, this mass shooting occurred on actually not on public property
Unknown Speaker• -
but on private property.
Council Member Henry Lo• -
And I know at the moment the space is empty, but I would imagine probably that was one question to be asked too is that what has to be done with the space as well. I mean, again, I know it is part of property, but again, you know, given it was the site of the shooting, it is in some ways considered secret ground, given what occurred there.
Unknown Speaker• -
Council Member Ngo?
Unknown Speaker• -
Yeah, so here's the kind of like the issue at stake here.
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
You ask 10 people, you're going to have 10 different opinions, 10 different locations, 10 different ways. You ask 100 people, you're going to have 100 different ways. I think what we need to do is figure out let's get the 10 people or let's get the 100 people let them figure out the best 5-10 ways whittle it down and then have that purpose that structure to move forward before we get there we're just going to go around in circles so we need to have a group to brainstorm and move forward and the memorial is for the city it's private property So I doubt we can touch private property or take over that. It'll have to be public property where it's accessible to anyone who wants to go visit and pay tribute to the victims.
Unknown Speaker• -
But those...
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
and I look forward to hearing their thoughts and working with them. And they're going to get our support.
Unknown Speaker• -
Council Member Lo?
Unknown Speaker• -
Yes.
Unknown Speaker• -
You know, I mean, even whatever the makeup of this committee is,
Council Member Henry Lo• -
and I think that is something that we need to at least address first,
Unknown Speaker• -
you know, I, again, look at the example, you know, at the post-moral,
Unknown Speaker• -
So what I liked in their methodology is that yes, there was a committee, but that committee
Council Member Henry Lo• -
also conducted town halls and forums and surveys. I do think that's really important to have community involvement. And again, I'd be curious to study this example more because again, that incident occurred on private property, occurred at a nightclub, actually very similar to the store of ballroom.
Unknown Speaker• -
And if I look at this summary of the project,
Council Member Henry Lo• -
it's that the monument is actually on the site of the nightclub. And so, yes, it's prayer property, but, you know, nonetheless,
Unknown Speaker• -
through the methodology of the outreach, in that example,
Council Member Henry Lo• -
the conclusion of this process did entail turning the site itself into a memorial. and I think that that's something we need to consider as well. And again, maybe that's the task of this advisory committee,
Unknown Speaker• -
but I think that, yes, it may be easy to say, well, converting public property,
Council Member Henry Lo• -
but I think that perhaps it could be robust, it could be public, it could be as well as private. I think that there are several possibilities. You know, I remember when some of us were in Vegas for a conference, I know the pro-tem and I went to visit Las Vegas' Resiliency Center, and one of the things that they pointed out that I had a chance to visit was actually the community healing garden. And now, yes, that was on public property, the community healing garden, but as the report here shows that Clark County where the shooting in Mandalay Bay had occurred, I mean it's taken them many years to get to this point to shoot a monument and it looks like again through their methodology they were able to also work with private property owners, if
Unknown Speaker• -
I'm not mistaken in this case MGM Grand made a donation of property. So I just think that
Unknown Speaker• -
you know, I think we can set broad parameters so that I think that it creates a process that's
Unknown Speaker• -
inclusive as well as robust in its recommendations and I think can provide recommendations that
Council Member Henry Lo• -
in itself it could be a robust memorial to what has occurred on the 21st. Because I think, you know, also remember too that ultimately what we establish needs to also have the ability to continue to resonate with those who visited. Whether they're, again, hypothetically, let's say we establish something next year. whoever visits it has to resonate those who may have experienced it to those who come maybe 10 years from now and understand what took place and and I admit I have not visited all of the sites that are in this recommendation but I will say that I did visit the healing garden in Las Vegas and I will say you
Unknown Speaker• -
know it's small I mean it's in a triangle if you will it's I mean look at
Unknown Speaker• -
an area where it's basically three roads
Council Member Henry Lo• -
form, well, I guess a,
Unknown Speaker• -
yeah, I call it triangle, you know, but that traffic triangle was enough space to
Unknown Speaker• -
create a garden, and that garden is small, but, you know,
Council Member Henry Lo• -
I mean, it's pretty powerful. It has
Unknown Speaker• -
the names of victims. It has a
Unknown Speaker• -
running fountain, and what actually found interesting for me is that although it's intersected
Unknown Speaker• -
by three roads, it
Council Member Henry Lo• -
also had the effect of being very calming, despite being intersected
Unknown Speaker• -
by three roads. And so I think, you know, I think that's probably one problem is that
Council Member Henry Lo• -
we have to look at all options as opposed to saying, well, maybe it'd be public property. I think that, again, I don't know what's being planned right now by the owners of the store ballroom, the former store ballroom, but as of today, I mean, it still looks empty from
Unknown Speaker• -
what I can tell.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
Thank you. Mayor Potempo?
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
If I can suggest maybe staff can do a little bit of deeper dive on some of these and other monuments maybe that have been established in the area and just to look at what their process is. Just in thinking through what this process might look like for us, it will probably require sitting at staff time or a consultant to be brought on board to help organize this process for outreach and organizing whatever committee, however that takes shape.
Unknown Speaker• -
resources will be needed to organize that and the process that is ultimately determined
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
to figure out what the memorial will look like and the outreach that's going to be needed
Unknown Speaker• -
to do all that.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
So looking to see how that process was resourced in these other areas, whether that was the city or the county, I don't know. If we can add that additional kind of question for filling out this matrix for information
Unknown Speaker• -
on these. And then my question too is on these committee members, right, who ultimately decided who to be on this and appointed them to this, if that was the governing body for that jurisdiction or someone else.
Unknown Speaker• -
I have no idea how that would provide some guidance for us in terms of how to maybe move forward on forming our own committee.
and then just if as staff or whoever is doing putting this together kind of
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
gathers additional information of these other kind of questions along the lines of what we're
Unknown Speaker• -
asking here I know a little scattered because it's we're just starting this kind of process
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
if there are other answers or other information they kind of come upon I think we could probably report this out, either a special meeting or a future agenda item in October, November,
Unknown Speaker• -
whatever time frame.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
Understanding that, right, this is not something that's going to get done in the next six months, and even optimistic, probably not in the next year. But we do want, I will put out there, right, I want to make sure that this is an outreach intensive process, that we gather as much input and feedback, particularly from the victims and their families on how this should take take shape but also from the wider community that was impacted by the shooting and that's still impacted by
Unknown Speaker• -
the shooting to make sure that as much of there are as many opportunities for
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
people to provide their input and feedback and to be part of this process of getting to the actual memorial being built along the way right it's not something we want to rush and it's not something that we should rush and clearly from looking at these other memorials it's not something that they have rushed either and we want to make sure it's a
Unknown Speaker• -
very intentional process at that so knowing that we're going to have to be patient in that and
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
that it's going to require a lot of work how do we resource that how did these other organizations
Unknown Speaker• -
and entities resource that and making me take some lessons here and report back yeah if i may just
Unknown Speaker• -
CHIME IN. YOU ARE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT. IT IS TOUGH. THERE IS NOT ONE SINGLE BLUEPRINT FOR ANY OF THE RESPONSES TO THESE TRAGEDIES.
Unknown Speaker• -
YOU KNOW, EVEN JUST THE SIX THAT WE HAVE TAKEN A LOOK AT, THEY HAVE BEEN DEALT WITH VERY DIFFERENTLY.
Unknown Speaker• -
IN SANDY HOOK, THE CITY COUNCIL APPOINTED NINE RESIDENTS, JUST RESIDENTS THAT DIDN'T NECESSARILY HAVE A CONNECTION TO THE TRAGEDY. AND THEY WENT THROUGH A VERY
Diana Garcia• -
robust outreach process and fundraising process for the Route 91 shooting in Las Vegas. The Clark County Commissioners actually asked the governor to appoint the members of the commission and they were guided in part by some county staff.
Unknown Speaker• -
We mentioned the Pulse nightclub. In that instance, the nightclub owner was very, very committed to developing a memorial on that property.
Unknown Speaker• -
It was extremely important to them.
Unknown Speaker• -
So that was something that they were very invested in, and they've been invested in the process throughout.
Unknown Speaker• -
But if you take a look at the shooting that happened at the Borderline Bar and Grill,
Diana Garcia• -
you'll notice that the memorial there wasn't on that property.
Unknown Speaker• -
It was on city property or park district property, I should say. So just a few things to consider.
Unknown Speaker• -
There's no one blueprint or one solution.
Unknown Speaker• -
Really, cities and communities have all had very different solutions to all of these questions,
Unknown Speaker• -
so all very good questions to consider.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
And I'd just also suggest maybe reach out to L.A. County as well. Potentially there are resources there that can help us supplement the research
Unknown Speaker• -
and other gathering information and potentially this process for gathering input right this is
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
not just something that impacted us here at mawri park but it was very a very county-wide impact as
Unknown Speaker• -
well uh and i think they my guess is they'd probably be open to at least partnering with us
Unknown Speaker• -
on this whether they can provide some financial resources as well for making sure that this
Unknown Speaker• -
process is robust i think is something we can pose to them too any other questions or comments
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
Thank you for that report. I also want to say that along with what Mayor Portem just said, I saw in some of the memorials that some of them got state grants or monies. So being able to look not just at county but also state and seeing how we can get our state senator or assembly member to help us get some funds for that. and then also I think sometimes we bypass there's a lot of different people that were impacted by this shooting but also taking youth voice into consideration as well a lot of students in this area were impacted by this saw it on a daily basis but I think there's if there's one way we can incorporate that voice or that you know of students that would be great but I look forward to future meetings and I think this is going to be a continued work.
Unknown Speaker• -
And so if we can just start to get the ball rolling on this and start getting some
Unknown Speaker• -
committee form, that would be great. But I think we're making some good segue,
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
good conversation here tonight on this project.
Unknown Speaker• -
Any other questions or comments? Thank you.
Unknown Speaker• -
So we'll go ahead and jump to item
Unknown Speaker• -
6A,
Unknown Speaker• -
which is a resolution on Hispanic Heritage Month.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
I asked to bring this forward
Unknown Speaker• -
because we're going to be
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
celebrating Hispanic Heritage Month,
Unknown Speaker• -
not just in our country, but here in Monterey Park.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
And we know we have a lot of events commemorating Hispanic Heritage Month
Unknown Speaker• -
that are being organized by our Parks and Rec Department, but also our library and throughout the city.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
So I wanted to thank those people,
Unknown Speaker• -
Robert and Kristen, for all the work that you're doing to help commemorate that.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
But I wanted to read some parts of the resolution that is here before us commemorating and proclaiming Hispanic Heritage Month between September 15th through October 15th. It says, be it resolved by the Council of the City of Monterey Park as follows, section one, it says the City Council finds as follows, the City of Monterey Park is honored to join citizens nationwide as we begin observing September 15th as the beginning of National Hispanic Heritage Month because it is the anniversary of Independence Day for Latin American countries, Costa Rica, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, and Nicaragua,
Unknown Speaker• -
in addition to Mexico and Chile,
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
celebrate their Independence Days on September 16th and September 18th, respectively. The observance started in 1968 as Hispanic Heritage Week under President Johnson. It was expanded by President Reagan in 1988 to cover 30 days beginning on September 15th. Many Hispanic Americans are the descendants of the Arowaks, Puerto Rico, the Aztecs, and Mexico, the Incas in South America, the Maya in Central America, and the Tainos in Cuba, Puerto Rico, and other places, and Africa and Spain. Every year since 1988, from September 15th to October 15th, our country has celebrated Hispanic culture with the greater community to highlight the rich heritage, arts, histories, food, music, and traditions of Latin American nations, while honoring and paying tribute to all of their contributions to our city and society. We recognize that Hispanics are an estimated 17,412 residents, totaling 28.5% of the city of Monterey Park. We understand that Hispanic Americans represent a vibrant and thriving part of our diverse community. Their histories and cultures stretch centuries and contributions of those who come to our community add new chapters to our city's history. Hispanics have profoundly and positively influenced the U.S. and Monterey Park through centuries-old traditions and customs that are embraced and valued in our city. The theme this year, actually, for National Hispanic Heritage Month is prosperity, power, and progress recognizes the significant achievements of the Hispanic community in the economic and political industries. Hispanics are a key contributor to the economic prosperity of the U.S. Nearly one in four businesses in Monterey Park is Hispanic-owned, and Hispanic-owned businesses contribute over $800 billion to the U.S. economy annually. The City of Monterey Park recognizes all Hispanic populations and outreach groups that help increase cultural awareness, education, enrichment, and community engagement with our residents. Through their support and community involvement, our city has continued to become a more culturally diverse and welcoming city for everyone. And I think it speaks to the great community we have here in Monterey Park and the diverse community that we have here. Monterey Park. So now there for be it resolved that the City of Monterey Park California hereby proclaim September 15 through October 15th as Hispanic Heritage Month and encourages all its citizens, businesses, organizations, and public entities to honor and recognize all the contributions made and the significant presence of Hispanic and Latino Americans in the United States and celebrate the heritage and culture. So I will make a motion to approve this resolution. Do I have a second? Second. Second by Council Member Yard.
Unknown Speaker• -
you if we can have a vote.
City Clerk Maychelle Yee• -
Approved unanimously. Thank you.
Unknown Speaker• -
And we'll go ahead and jump to thank you,
Unknown Speaker• -
Council. We'll jump to City Communications.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you. You want to start, Mr.
Unknown Speaker• -
Council Member Lo? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Let's see.
Unknown Speaker• -
For my report on August 19th,
Council Member Henry Lo• -
I attended a workshop by the organization Peace and Compassion SGV, and they were an organization that was created
Unknown Speaker• -
during the death of the pandemic, unfortunately during the rise of the,
Council Member Henry Lo• -
unfortunate rise of anti-Asian hate.
Unknown Speaker• -
And so this is an organization that's,
Council Member Henry Lo• -
as the name implies, is to promote peace and compassion in our community. Peace and Compassion SGV hosted a hate crime workshop that actually was attended by the district attorney.
Unknown Speaker• -
And I do want to thank the district attorney
Council Member Henry Lo• -
for not only speaking to the crowd, which was very well attended at Langley Senior Center, but stayed for most of the workshop. And essentially, the workshop consisted of lessons on how to do bystander interventions and training, as well as how to report instances of hate.
Unknown Speaker• -
And so again, we thank peace and compassion, as well as our district attorney, Mr. Gascon,
Council Member Henry Lo• -
for being there on 19th on August 21st. I and many of my colleagues here attended the opening of the Monterey Park Hope Resiliency Center and again we are very pleased to see since we just talked earlier tonight about monuments and part of the healing process I'm just excited to see that the Resiliency Center is open
Unknown Speaker• -
up and running to make sure that
Council Member Henry Lo• -
as a community we are collectively healing from the trauma of the 21st
Unknown Speaker• -
and then on the
Unknown Speaker• -
The, let's see, on September, I'm sorry, August 25th, I believe,
Council Member Henry Lo• -
I and I think some of us attended a solidarity rally at Garfield Medical Center in support of nurses at Garfield Medical Center. And again, I think it's important to acknowledge that, you know, these were the frontline workers during the depth of the pandemic who continue to take care of our community. and as they care for the health and well-being of our community, it's important to also support the well-being of these health care workers and nurses.
Unknown Speaker• -
That's it for me.
Council Member Henry Lo• -
And I also would like to ask at the future agenda item, if we can maybe get a staff update to see how we are doing in terms of, you know, not too long ago we passed, actually, yeah, about a year ago, we passed a Vision Zero resolution as well as a Complete Streets resolution. And a lot of those focus of the two resolutions is to create more pedestrian friendly and
Unknown Speaker• -
safer streets.
Council Member Henry Lo• -
And even earlier tonight, you know, we had someone speak up about traffic at Chandler
Unknown Speaker• -
and Hellman.
Council Member Henry Lo• -
So I think it would be important for us, the council and community to know that it's one thing to pass a resolution, but how are we actually realizing the goals of those resolutions.
Unknown Speaker• -
so yeah
Council Member Henry Lo• -
so that's something I'd like to see in the future agenda item
Unknown Speaker• -
and I think that's it for me Thank you Councilmember Lo Councilmember Yu Last Saturday we attended the grand opening of the Hero Christian Medical Center in El Monte we are grateful to have such a wonderful partner
Unknown Speaker• -
during pandemic and they have expanded their medical center with advanced technologies
Unknown Speaker• -
to help our underserved population. So congratulations with the grand opening.
Unknown Speaker• -
On September 22nd, I had a great meeting with the high school student from our junior friends at the library. I think all the council have done that, and I think I'm the last one that scheduled. I was very impressed with their participations
Unknown Speaker• -
and overwhelming questions.
Unknown Speaker• -
They're interested to learn about how to choose the right career and how to be successful in moving up the corporate ladder. And I'm looking forward to do more sessions for them. On September 21st, we attend the Chinatown Service Center Resilient Center opening at the Sierra Vista Park. There were different booths set up and offering various services
Unknown Speaker• -
and training classes for public and those in need, especially those with mental health issues. So congratulations with the grand opening. Thank you. That's all for me
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
Thank you councilmember you councilmember go all right, so I attended many of the same events, but I will start with the first one which is August 17th, and I'm just gonna say it was an epic event That was the Mario Park Police annual promotions. So epic is the key word there On August 18th, right around the storm that we had, I attended the Asian American Economic Development Enterprise, which is located in our city. They held their annual job and career fair in Alhambra at Almancer. Then, I think this is Saturday, the day where the storm was coming in, we attended the Union Church, which is off of New Avenue, City of Monterey Park. they held their health fair and food giveaway. So I was happy to be there along with our fire department. The cert card was there. Then the next day when the rain actually came in, a few of us attended the Mario Park Mantle Ray Annual Awards Banquet.
Unknown Speaker• -
Oh, yeah, that's right.
Council Member Vinh T. Ngo• -
And it was raining. It was definitely raining, heavy rain that day. Then the Resiliency Center on the 21st And then last, actually on August 23rd, I was asked to attend the welcome back to school as well as orientation for staff for Garvey School District held at Garvey Middle School. So I think there were about 600 staff who showed up. This is the first welcome back in person for all, not only staff, but teachers as well as community members who were involved with Garvey. And then last night, the mayor and I attended the educator night at Bruggemeyer Library. Got a chance to see some of the work our library does in supporting educators in the community, helping them with resources, and allowing the public to utilize some of the help that probably a lot of educators didn't know about, including free books, many free books.
Unknown Speaker• -
So that is it for me.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you, Council Member Ngo.
Unknown Speaker• -
Mayor Potemwong?
Unknown Speaker• -
Yeah, attended a lot of the same events.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
again congratulations to all the police department officers who were promoted and welcomed into the department on the 17th of August appreciate everyone who's stepping up and and putting themselves at risk to protect our community and serve the community attended the manta rays banquet congratulations to all the manta rays including the seniors who graduated and I know council member provide a scholarship or two scholarships I think to swimmers there they were graduating from high school and also sent off one of the coaches I think is leaving the manor a's so had a bittersweet swing off for him also attended the Hope Resiliency Center opening on the 21st congratulations and thank you to chat how service that I know one of our fellow council members serves on the board there but great opportunity and event put on to open the center I know that there are a lot of partners that put work into making the center a reality appreciate staff here at the city for helping to facilitate the actual physical facility to house the services that will be offered through the resiliency center going forward for now but all the the nonprofit partners and community-based organizations that are providing services through there for victims and others in the community who have been impacted by the shooting and continue to be impacted by the shooting. I want to remind everyone that there are services being provided there and I believe we are linking to their calendar on our own website for services that are being offered there and that continue to be offered at Langley Center and the library here for free.
Unknown Speaker• -
and then just wanted on a personal note
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
I think a few of us attended
Unknown Speaker• -
Helen Romero Shaw of SoCal Gas
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
her retirement party after 41 years of working for the gas company just last I think this was last week
Unknown Speaker• -
yeah last week
Unknown Speaker• -
so she decided to have her retirement party
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
here in the city of Barnes Park at traditional Goylan Noodle
Unknown Speaker• -
right about
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
two blocks away from here to help also to celebrate the resiliency of our own community
Unknown Speaker• -
in the wake of the shooting
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
and to provide support for a small business here in the city. But I wanted to just quickly note her long tenure of service to our community and to many communities in the region at the gas company and in many ways providing support for many decades to many community-based organizations.
Unknown Speaker• -
She served on the board. I think of a number of organizations, including Asian Youth Center,
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
that provides services here for some of our residents and families in Maori Park and in the region
Unknown Speaker• -
and a number of other nonprofits that she has served on the board
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
for many, many years. So she's a great community asset that I think, sad to see her go, but wished her all the best in her next phase of life, which she's saying will include a lot more travel
Unknown Speaker• -
than she has done in the last few years.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
So wish her well and wish her all the best.
Council Member Henry Lo• -
And also, she's probably many times
Unknown Speaker• -
in her capacity representing a gas company been before this day.
Council Member Thomas Wong• -
during public comment that's it for me sorry and I saw on LinkedIn so if this is not accurate but I believe Frank Hellman is being is returning as our water utility manager I don't know effective when if he's already started or not but wanted to welcome him back to the city of Murray Park worked with him when I was on the water board he was the water utility manager here in Murray Park so great to see him return to the city and great to see that that role that is been vacant for a little while now filled with someone who has great qualifications and is already familiar with the city so appreciate Frank and look forward to working with him
Unknown Speaker• -
going forward as well.
Thank you Mayor Portenburg.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
A lot of us attended some of the same events. I'm not going to try to mention a lot of those but I know that some of us attended the cause Soiree at the Boston Market Hall on August the 18th.
Unknown Speaker• -
I didn't hear anyone mention that.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
And a lot of us had the opportunity to work with COS this summer, a lot of their interns, promoting civic engagement and preparing the next group of leaders here in the San Gabriel Valley.
Unknown Speaker• -
So great.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
Several of us were able to attend and help honor a lot of those interns
Unknown Speaker• -
that participated.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
On August the 19th, I also attended the community health fair at Union Church with my daughter and got to see a lot of the activities that were going on at the church, a lot of food
Unknown Speaker• -
giveaways.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
So the church does a lot of great community outreach in terms of not just providing food, but also a lot of the services over there. Great to see the fire department there. There's some programs offering a lot of information to residents. So thank you guys for being out there. on the 19th I attended the Lions Club dinner and our city had certificates for them for a lot of the work that they did also honoring the work that they did during the pandemic to provide a lot of services and help to needy families in the community throughout the San Gabriel Valley on August the 26th I attended the O'Hambra Teachers Association did a welcome back breakfast for all of their teachers, welcoming them back to the start of the new school year.
Unknown Speaker• -
So that was a lot of fun.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
My daughters loved attending, especially because they get to make their own waffles. On August the 28th, I was able to attend the Alhambra City Council meeting for the reorganization of their new council. And we wished former Mayor Adele Andrade-Stadler and thanked her for her service to Alhambra and the partnership that we had with our own city and welcomed new mayor, Roz Mazza,
Unknown Speaker• -
as the new mayor of Alhambra,
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
and the new vice mayor, Sasha Renee Perez,
Unknown Speaker• -
who many might not know,
Unknown Speaker• -
but was actually a former student of mine.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
On August the 20th, I'm sorry, on August the 30th, I went to the Garfield Health Center.
Unknown Speaker• -
They're offering free flu shots. It's flu season, so I'm just doing a shout out for them. If you still haven't gotten me a flu shot,
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
I know it's still early, but you can get yours there for free.
Unknown Speaker• -
So go out and check them out.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
I took my daughter with me so we can both get the flu shot together.
Unknown Speaker• -
So make it, it's not that fun, but it kind of is. Make it a family event. That's what I always do.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
I also on that same day got to attend the joint committee with the Old Hamburg Unified School District, which was also attended by our city manager and our assistant city manager, to discuss moving forward with the district, not just various issues that relate and pertain to the district and our city, but also moving forward with part of our strategic plan, which is civic engagement, and looking at how we can incorporate eighth graders and bring them into our city and teach them how our city operates. Director of the City. City Government. City Attorney. So we're still working and aring on the details of that. But I think it's a real it was a really good start to meet with a lot of the stakeholders in Alhambra Unified to try to get them here. I also look forward to maybe partnering with Garvey. Maybe Montebello and try to get some other schools involved as well. And lastly. Oh actually not lastly. I also attended the along with many of us here the strike by the nurses. who were striking out here on Garfield, at the Garfield Hospital. I took my family, again, made it a family event. I attended every day that they were out there striking. And lastly, last night, Vin and I both attended the Educator Night, which was really amazing, a lot of great resources. I went back to my high school and shared a lot of those with my department,
Unknown Speaker• -
a lot of the social science teachers.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
So I appreciate the library for putting out that event. if we can do it again I know September is kind of hard for teachers we're starting the school year it's back to school night a lot happening we're trying to get everything settled so we'd love to see that happen again and partnering with maybe the union of the Heimer Teachers Association maybe Garvey Education Association get a little bit more of a turnout and share a lot of those amazing resources that we have here in the library so thank you so much for hosting that my daughters loved it they all left with the books
Unknown Speaker• -
because I appreciated that.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
Of course, they fell asleep by the time we got home.
Unknown Speaker• -
So anyhow, that's all I have.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
And just in terms of new agenda items, I know that October 5th,
Unknown Speaker• -
in conjunction with Hispanic Heritage Month, is Latina Equal Payday.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
So I just wanted to bring that up and maybe as a possible resolution. I know Council Member Lo was talking about that earlier. And I know that also October, the month of October,
Unknown Speaker• -
I wrote it down, I'm sorry.
Is, sorry, I took down some notes here.
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
Oh, yes, October is National Domestic Violence Awareness Month. So if we can bring a resolution maybe to commemorate, but also to bring up this important issue that impacts many people, not just throughout our country, but even our own community.
Unknown Speaker• -
Thank you. And with that, are there any?
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
Oh, yes, and I would also like to end.
Unknown Speaker• -
I almost forgot.
Unknown Speaker• -
We are not having a city council meeting on September 20th,
Council Member Jose Sanchez• -
so we have canceled it, and our next scheduled council meeting is October 4th.
Unknown Speaker• -
So put it in your calendars, October 4th.
Unknown Speaker• -
But with that, we will close tonight's meeting at 10.32 p.m. Have a good night.